Erin Caffey Teen Killer Murders Mother & Brothers

Erin Caffey was fifteen when she murdered her mother and two brothers. According to court documents Erin Caffey began dating an older man her parents did not approve on. On the night of the murders Erin Caffey boyfriend and another man entered the home, shot her father, mother and two younger siblings before setting the house on fire. Erin Caffey father would survive the horrific attack. This teen killer would be sentenced to life with parole

Erin Caffey 2023 Information

SID Number:    04889597

TDCJ Number:    01548417

Name:    CAFFEY,ERIN MICHELLE

Race:    W

Gender:    F

Age:    30

Maximum Sentence Date:    LIFE SENTENCE        CUMULATIVE OFFENSES

Current Facility:    CHRISTINA MELTON CRAIN UNIT

Projected Release Date:    NOT AVAILABLE

Parole Eligibility Date:    2038-03-01

Inmate Visitation Eligible:    YES

Erin Caffey Other News

ERIN Caffey is 24, and has been in a high-security prison in Gatesville, Texas, for eight years.

My first impression of her was that she seemed gentle and unthreatening, as befits someone who came from a loving, stable home, had never been in trouble and sang in the church choir every Sunday with her mum, dad and two younger brothers.

But to say she’s not what she seems is the understatement of the century. In fact, Erin Caffey is the most dangerous woman I have met in my life.

She organised the killing of her family at the age of 16.

Erin accomplices were her boyfriend Charlie Wilkinson, 18, his pal Charles Waid, 20, and Waid’s girlfriend Bobbi Johnson, 18.

The two men did the killing. Caffey’s mother Penny was shot, then stabbed with a samurai sword and almost decapitated.

Erin 13-year-old brother, Matthew, was shot in the head.

Her eight-year-old brother Tyler was repeatedly stabbed with a samurai sword.

Caffey father Terry was shot five times and left for dead as the house was torched to the ground. But he miraculously survived.

Why did she do it?

The only motive appears to be that a few days before the murder spree, Penny and Terry told their daughter she could no longer see Wilkinson.

Filled with lovesick rage, Erin ordered her boyfriend and his buddy to carry out her revenge.

“I was shocked, angry and hurt, this was the guy I was supposed to spend the rest of my life with and he loved me,” she told The Sun. “We were going to get married.”

When the police arrested them all, she claimed to have been drugged and kidnapped. But the other three all immediately said she was the ringleader.

“I’ve never come across anyone as dangerous as Erin,” said criminal therapist Israel Lewis, who worked with her after her capture.

Caffey was interviewed for a new series called Killer Women With Piers Morgan.

“In Erin Caffey’s case you know you are looking at evil. She is the most evil woman I have ever met,” Morgan said.

The most unsettling aspect of Caffey’s crime is that it is so utterly inexplicable. There were no warning signs, no history of trouble.

“You know, I was voted when we went to youth camp ‘Most Fun Loving Person’,” she said.

“What the hell happened?” I asked.

“I guess what it all boils down to is choices,” Erin Caffey said, almost matter-of-factly.

“When I look back on it now, this was all just stupid. I mean, for what? They weren’t beating me, they weren’t starving me to death. I had it made.”

None of the four involved were drunk or had taken drugs on the night of the murders.

As Wilkinson and Waid did the killing the girls waited in a car.

Records of calls between Erin and Wilkinson nailed her lie that she had been the victim of a kidnap.

Perhaps the most surreal moment of our interview came when she sang Amazing Grace, pitch-perfect.

Her father, the man who she tried to have killed, is the only person who still visits her.

Caffey is serving a minimum of 42 years and won’t be eligible for parole until she’s 59.

Wilkinson and Waid are serving life without parole but were spared the death penalty because Terry Caffey asked for it to be taken off the table. “I wanted them to have the chance to find remorse,” he explained.

Terry Caffey previously told Nightline what happened that night.

“It was so loud and it’s even hard to describe,” he said. “I mean, can you imagine someone standing over you and shooting when you’re sound asleep and now you’re being attacked in your bed?”

“I found out that Tyler, eight-year-old little Tyler, was hiding upstairs in a closet and the two killers, Charlie and Charles [Waid], took turns stabbing him to death,” Caffey said. “The hardest thing [was] to hear that. I remember when I heard that, I just couldn’t believe that’s how they did [it], and it goes back to that guilt and I felt I should have been able to save them and I couldn’t.

He crawled the length of four football fields to find help after being shot five times. He says he wanted to die until he found out that his daughter was alive.

“Then I had something to live for, I had some hope, so I began to fight,” he said. “But that hope would be short-lived because just within half an hour of finding out she was alive, my sister came to me and told me [Erin] had been arrested and had been charged with murder.”

Just a few days after the murders, Terry Caffey would make the eight-hour round trip to a prison to see the person who planned the family murder and had wanted him dead too.

He does it every month.

“Do you believe her version of events?” I asked Terry.

“I feel like for the most part I believe her,” he replied.

“I honestly believe she was not the mastermind. This was a vulnerable 16-year-old girl with a controlling, psychopathic guy.”

This might just hold water if it were not for a previous boyfriend, Michael Washburn, revealing that Erin had said to him too that she wanted her family dead.

Back to Terry Caffey.

“Do you forgive her?” I asked.

“I do forgive her,” he said. “I have to forgive her.”

Erin Caffey Videos

Frequently Asked Questions

Erin Caffey FAQ

Erin Caffey Photos

Erin Caffey Other News

16 year old Erin Caffey made her first appearance before a Rains County Judge Monday.

Caffey and three co-defendants are all accused of killing her mother Penny Caffey and her brothers Matthew and Tyler Caffey, before setting the family’s house on fire in Emory. Erin Caffey’s father Terry was shot several times in the attack, but survived. Ironically, he was one of those in court asking for Erin to be allowed to come back home.

Before the judge issued a gag order, defense attorneys confirmed that Terry Caffey testified on his daughter’s behalf, asking that she be allowed to go home with him rather than staying in juvenile custody in Hunt County. Erin’s grandmother also testified for her, but neither testimony would sway the judge, who ordered Erin to continue to be held another 15 business days.

Another issue is still pending in the case – whether she will be tried as an adult.  KLTV caught up with both the prosecution and the defense after the hearing.

“She’s facing a certification hearing. It’s not ready to go yet. The psychologist must evaluate her and her probation officer must work on her family report on her,” said William Howard McDowell, Erin’s defense attorney.

We have received the initial case from the Rains County Sheriff’s Department, however the case is still under investigation there are additional things to be done,” said Rains County Attorney Robert Vititow.

As for the other defendants, they were all indicted Monday morning by a Rains County Grand Jury. Bobbi Gale Johnson, Charles Waid, and Charlie Wilkinson were each indicted for capital murder for the deaths of Penny, Matthew, and Tyler Caffey.

One of them also faces a new charge. Wilkinson, Erin’s boyfriend, was also indicted for attempted escape. According to the indictment he dug a hole in the wall of his cell at the Rains County Jail on March 25th.

Rains County has requested the assistance of the Attorney General’s office. They are already there, and Lisa Tanner, who specializes in capital murder cases, is there to help. They will be there for the entirety of all four trials.

https://www.kltv.com/story/8132265/dad-wants-daughter-in-triple-murder-to-go-home/

Erin Caffey Dr Phil Videos