pennsylvania death row | My Crime Library

Andre Staton Pennsylvania Death Row

Andre Staton was sentenced to death by the State of Pennsylvania for the murder of an ex girlfriend. According to court documents Andre Staton was abusing his girlfriend so she would leave him and file an order of protection. Andre Staton would break into her mothers home and stab her to death in front of her three children. Andre Staton would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death

Andre Staton 2022 Information

Parole Number: 793GM
Age: 58
Date of Birth: 05/18/1963
Race/Ethnicity: BLACK
Height: 5′ 10″
Gender: MALE
Citizenship: USA
Complexion: MEDIUM
Current Location: PHOENIX

Andre Staton More News

The record establishes that Andre Staton and Beverly Yohn were in an intimate relationship during which Appellant was physically and verbally abusive. As a result of the abuse, Yohn and her two sons moved to the residence of Yohn’s mother, Penny Lantz. In January of 2004, Yohn reported to police that Appellant had struck her. She subsequently filed a Protection From Abuse (“PFA”) petition, and a temporary PFA order was entered against Appellant on January 27, 2004. Following a subsequent hearing, the trial court entered a final PFA order on February 19, 2004.

While at a bar several days later on February 24, 2004, Andre Staton told the bartender about his frustrations with his girlfriend, and about how he had peeked in the window at her the night before. He also indicated that he gave her a substantial amount of money for a house that he could no longer live in, but stated that he would soon take care of the matter. The next morning, Andre Staton was seen inside a parked car approximately one and one-half blocks away from the residence of Yohn’s mother. Yohn’s son, Justin, was outside the home when he saw Andre Staton run up to the rear porch of the residence with his finger to his lips, directing Justin to be quiet. Appellant then kicked in the door and entered the kitchen. With Yohn’s son, Jeremy, in the room, Staton opened his jacket, pulled out a knife, and began stabbing Yohn until she fell to the floor with the large knife still in her back. Appellant then fled through the back door, and encountered Justin outside waiting in the car to go to school. Appellant threw Justin from the car and drove away in it. Yohn died later that day from her injuries. Appellant was thereafter charged with first degree murder, aggravated assault, burglary, criminal trespass, receiving stolen property, and theft by unlawful taking.

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/pa-supreme-court/1708327.html

Mark Spotz Pennsylvania Death Row

Mark Spotz was sentenced to death by the State of Pennsylvania for the shooting deaths of four people. According toc court documents Mark Spotz would open fire killing his brother. Over the next three days Mark Spotz would murder three women in three different counties during violent carjackings. Mark Spotz would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death.

Mark Spotz 2022 Information

Parole Number: 5552W
Age: 50
Date of Birth: 02/14/1971
Race/Ethnicity: WHITE
Height: 6′ 00″
Gender: MALE
Citizenship: USA
Complexion: LIGHT
Current Location: PHOENIX

Mark Spotz More News

Mark Spotz and Christina Noland were young and infatuated with each other. Spotz even brought Noland to meet his family — but what followed was a bizarre sibling feud that ignited a shocking series of murders.

On February 1, 1995, a woman was walking across a bridge in Pine Grove, Pennsylvania when she looked down and realized a woman was laying at the bottom. She contacted police, who rushed to the scene and discovered June Ohlinger, 52, was dead. She had been shot in the back of the head. They soon learned her purse and car were missing too, making a carjacking or robbery likely.

Ohlinger was a devoted mother who had been happily planning the baby shower for her first grandchild. She worked as a cashier at a local minimart and had been on her way to her job, police believed, when she had been taken and killed.

“Pine Grove is a very small town, not a lot of crime, so June Ohlinger probably never thought anything would happen to her early morning opening up the store,” Laura Venet, the documentarian behind “Spree Killer,” told “Killer Couples,” airing Sundays at 8/7c on Oxygen

As authorities got to work on their investigation, they received a call from the owner of a local carwash who had discovered a purse, clothing, and other personal items that belonged to Ohlinger. The car wash had surveillance video, so police were able to lay eyes on the perpatrator. They watched video of Ohlinger’s vehicle arriving at the car wash — and two people, a man and a woman, coming out and tossing the items.

Police knew they had to locate the car and the two suspects, but the following day tragedy struck again just 70 miles from where Ohlinger’s body had been found. Penny Gunnet, a 41-year-old manager of a tax firm, had been found dead under her car on the side of the road. She had been shot in the head and run over.

“Penny Gunnet was someone who was the last person you would think would be attacked. She was known as a loving mother, a great wife. Everyone was stumped. No one knew how or why she could’ve ended up in this situation,” Venet said.

There were disturbing similarities to the murder of Ohlinger: Gunnet’s purse was also missing, and the same kind of bullets were found at the scene. Her husband told police the last time he saw her that morning, she had been heading off to work.

“The police have so many similarities in these horrible crimes and they’re trying to determine what the motivation could be and they surmise the killer is really desperate to have a car and money and those are the driving factors that fuel this case across the state,” Janis Wilson, a former reporter with The Patriot-News told producers.

Authorities got another break when Ohlinger’s car was found abanonded on the side of the road. They dusted the vehicle for fingerprints and found three sets: one belonging to Ohlinger, one belonging to an unknown person, and one belonging to Mark Spotz, a 23-year-old with a lengthy criminal history who was currently wanted for the murder of his brother, Dustin Spotz.

They tracked down Dustin Spotz’s fiancé, who told them the whole story. On the evening of January 31, they had all been together at the Spotz boys’ mother’s home, and Spotz had brought Noland over to meet them. At one point, Spotz got tired and went to take a nap, so Dustin’s fiancé’s young son decided to play a prank on him and dangle a gerbil in his face, which infuriated Spotz. Spotz began cursing the boy out, Dustin got involved to defend him, and the fight soon turned violent, with Dustin stabbing Spotz with a kitchen knife. Spotz then went, got a gun, and shot his brother to death. He and Noland then fled the scene.

The fiancé also told them that both brothers had a very troubled upbringing, enduring a lot of abuse and bouncing around between homes. While Mark Spotz turned to crime, including incidents of arson, he was still known to be very charismatic and had a way with women.

Noland, however, had no criminal history, a stable upbringing, and had generally been regarded as a good kid.

“The heart wants what the heart wants and Christina wanted Mark,” Wilson surmised.

Noland, would soon turn on Spotz, though. She contacted police and confirmed Spotz had killed and abducted both Gunnet and Ohlinger.

“She told the police Mark had lost his temper because a teenage boy had been teasing him with a gerbil and he had gotten into a fight with his brother, and his brother had gotten killed,” Wilson told producers.

Afterward, they fled. They carjacked Ohlinger to find a new vehicle and robbed her for money, and Spotz shot her to death and kicked her body off the overpass. Time passed and they realized they had kept her car for too long, which is why Spotz then carjacked and killed Gunnet. Noland tried to follow him in Ohlinger’s car, but soon lost track of him as he was a better driver. It was then she turned herself in to police and cooperated with the investigation.

“We asked her over and over again, ‘Why she did you stay with him?’ She gave answers to say she was afraid, she was afraid of Mark, she was afraid of what he would do in general if she would turn against him,” Detective John Sancenito, formerly of the North MIddletown Township police, told producers.

Then, yet another body was found. Tree trimmers uncovered the body of 71-year-old Betty Amstudz in the woods in nearby Cumberland County. Like the other victims, she had been shot to death and with the same type of gun. Her purse and car were missing. In an even more chilling turn of events, when they went to Amstudz’s home, they found the door ajar and groceries partially put it away. It was clear she had been taken by force from her own house.

By tracing her credit cards, they were able to track Spotz to a nearby motel. A brief standoff ensued, but Spotz eventually turned himself in. He had committed four murders in four days in four different counties. He was tried for first-degree murder in three counties and voluntary manslaughter in another for the death of his brother.

Noland took a deal and pled guilty to criminal homicide. She was sentenced to 12 to 20 years in prison for Ohlinger’s death and six to 30 years in prison for Gunnet’s death. In exhcange, she agreed to testify against Spotz.

In March 1996, Spotz’s trials began. He acted as his own lawyer and tried to pin all the murders on Noland. The strategy didn’t work. Spotz was found guilty in all four cases and handed down three death sentences. He is currently on death row.

Noland, meanwhile, was released in 2008 after spending 13 years in prison.

https://www.oxygen.com/killer-couples/crime-news/mark-spotz-christina-noland-go-on-pennsylvania-murder-spree

Christina Noland Photos

Wayne Smith Pennsylvania Death Row

Wayne Smith was sentenced to death by the State of Pennsylvania for the murder of a woman. According to court documents Wayne Smith was upset that the victim had denied his advances and proceeded to strangle her to death. Wayne Smith who was previously convicted of manslaughter would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death

Wayne Smith 2022 Information

Parole Number: 5260P
Age: 66
Date of Birth: 11/28/1955
Race/Ethnicity: BLACK
Height: 6′ 04″
Gender: MALE
Citizenship: USA
Complexion: MEDIUM
Current Location: PHOENIX

Wayne Smith More News

A second Delaware County jury has decided on a death sentence for a Chester man who was convicted nearly two decades ago in the murder of 26-year-old Eileen Jones.

Jurors deliberated for about six hours before returning the repeat-decision for Wayne Smith. The decision capped a life-or-death battle among expert witnesses, which played out this week in a penalty phase trial resulting from Smith’s death-sentence appeal to the state Supreme Court.

Smith, now 56, reportedly showed no reaction when the decision was announced, or when Judge James Bradley remanded him to death row at SCI Rockview — where his death by lethal injection would be imposed. No execution date has been set. The last person to be executed in Pennsylvania was Gary M. Heidnik, on July 6, 1999, under former Gov. Tom Ridge.

Smith is currently serving time in a Greene County prison for the Nov. 18, 1994, strangulation of Jones. The Eddystone mother of two was three months pregnant at the time of death.

Assistant District Attorney Erica Parham, spokeswoman for the D.A.’s office, said she anticipates further legal proceedings.

“However, we are very satisfied with the decision of the jury,” she said. “The jury appropriately determined that the defendant’s prior conviction for voluntary manslaughter of a bar patron with a machete, a commonwealth aggravating factor, outweighed any mitigating factor presented by the defense.”

Under Pennsylvania law, death by lethal injections can only be sought in cases in which aggravating circumstances are present.

Smith was one of two men charged in 1980 in the fatal stabbing of a Chester resident in a bar. He pleaded guilty to a manslaughter charge and served a two- to four-year jail term.

The previous conviction was one of two aggravating circumstances cited by the prosecution in 1995. The second was that Jones’ killing occurred during the commission of a second felony of attempted rape.

Parham noted that Ed Martin, Jones’ father, was in the courtroom throughout the week and left about an hour before the jury returned with a decision, shortly before 7:30 p.m.

“He bravely endured the proceedings this week,” Parham said “He has felt the loss of his daughter since 1994. His presence showed his commitment to justice, and the Office of the District Attorney is just as committed.”

Smith was convicted of first-degree murder in May 1995 and given a death sentence. At that time, after the verdict he turned and apologized to the victim’s family for the strangulation.

“I’ll never forgive myself,” said Smith. “I just hope that in time the family and her kids will forgive me,” he added, while beginning to cry.

Jones’ partially clothed body was fished from the waters of Ridley Creek near Ninth Street — between the Chester and Eddystone border — on Nov. 22, 1994.?

During the initial trial, the prosecution claimed Smith killed Jones after she rejected his sexual advances. Defense counsel Raymond Williams argued Smith killed the woman while in a cocaine-induced frenzy.

According to testimony given at trial this week, Smith had made an arrangement with Jones that she would give him sex in exchange for cocaine. After several hours spent with the victim, the sexual encounter occurred in a park near the Ninth Street Bridge, where the victim was later found.

Smith told police that at some point the two began wrestling on the ground, according to a statement read in court. He then became afraid that Jones, who is white, would say Smith had raped her. Smith said he did not believe a jury would believe him because he is black.

He strangled the woman and dragged her to the creek where her body was later discovered. Smith would have had to strangle Jones for two-and-a-half to three minutes to choke the life out of her, according to former Delaware County Medical Examiner Dr. Dimitri Contostavlos.

Smith initially lied to police about the murder, but later confessed, according to a taped statement played for the court.

He appealed the death penalty sentence to the state Supreme Court. The court affirmed the murder conviction in 2010, but ordered a new hearing on the death penalty. Because the murder conviction was upheld, only two options remained open to the new jury: Life imprisonment or death.

The appeals court determined that defense counsel’s “inadequate investigation” and “narrow focus on cocaine-induced psychosis as the key to the guilt phase, coupled with his disregard for other forms of mental health mitigating evidence, which would have been useful at the penalty phase, cannot be said to have been a reasonable strategy.”

Smith’s new attorney, William Wismer, offered testimony this week from Dr. George Woody, an expert in psychiatry and substance abuse, who found Smith’s fear that no one would believe him could have stemmed from childhood factors like abuse and neglect, exacerbated by cocaine use.

“I think that he developed a cocaine-induced paranoia and that cocaine magnified the problems he had with anger and anxiety and impulse control, and putting all that together it resulted in the behavior that caused (Jones’) death,” he said.

Neuropsychologist Carol Armstrong also told Wismer that Smith was severely impaired in his ability to reason and suffered post-traumatic stress disorder from his abusive childhood.

Armstrong said the chronic stresses Smith underwent in childhood likely resulted in brain damage and that his escape mechanism – long and intensive crack cocaine and alcohol abuse – could have induced psychosis.

But clinical and forensic psychiatrist Dr. Gerald Cooke told Assistant District Attorney Mary Mann that Armstrong had evaluated Smith inaccurately. There was no determination in her report how she came to diagnose him with PTSD, said Cooke, and none of the tests in which he was found to be impaired have a baseline “norm” for age, education, race and sex that psychiatrists use for comparison.

On seven tests with norms that Armstrong did administer, Cooke said Wayne Smith did not fall into the impaired range, and on three of those he even scored above normal.

Chester man gets death sentence for ’94 murder

John Small Pennsylvania Death Row

John Small was sentenced to death by the State of Pennsylvania for the sexual assault and murder of a woman. According to court documents John Small and James Frey would kidnap the victim who was brought to a remote location where she was sexually assaulted and beaten to death. Five weeks after the murder the victims body was found. John Small would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death

John Small 2022 Information

Parole Number: 9630P
Age: 62
Date of Birth: 11/14/1959
Race/Ethnicity: WHITE
Height: 6′ 01″
Gender: MALE
Citizenship: USA
Complexion: LIGHT
Current Location: PHOENIX

John Small More News

[O]n the evening of August 5, 1981, a group of people, including the victim, attended a party in the Borough of Hanover. Even though many of the attendees at the party were underage, large quantities of alcohol and marijuana were consumed. At some point during the evening, a fight erupted and the police were called to the scene. Prior to the arrival of the responding police officers, a group of the partygoers left in two separate vehicles and drove to a local tavern. After consuming more alcohol at the tavern, the group drove to a wooded area outside of Hanover, known as “the Pines.” Several members of the group departed. At one point, the victim left the remaining members of the group and went into the woods to relieve herself. She was followed by [John Small] and co-defendant James Frey. Sometime thereafter, witnesses testified that they heard the victim scream. An eyewitness, Larry Tucker, later testified at trial that he had followed [Small] into the woods and then watched [John Small] and the co-defendant grab the victim, throw her to the ground and say to her “you give it to everybody else.” [John Small] was seen shortly thereafter coming out of the woods with blood on his hands. Co-defendant Frey followed several minutes later and the remaining members of the group then left the Pines leaving the victim in the woods. The victim was never seen alive again and her body was found seven weeks later, in a spread eagle position, naked from the waist down with her shirt rolled around her neck, exposing her upper torso. Forensic evidence indicated that the cause of death was a head trauma.

No arrest was made for a number of years. Finally, police investigators learned that [John Small] had been making incriminating statements implicating himself in the murder. Linda Rhinehart testified that she overheard [John Small] at an arcade in Hanover state to some friends that: “I followed her into the woods ‘cause I was going to get some of that․ She won’t be a tease anymore. It’s amazing what a tire iron can do to hush someone making that much noise.” Cerenna Hughes testified that [Small] told her that after the night at the Pines, Cheryl “run away” and “she gave in, she gave up.” Harry H. Carper III testified that sometime during 1981, he visited [Small] at his home and [Small] stated “he might have killed” Cheryl Smith and that “he hit her over the top of her head.” Lastly, Janice Small, [Small’s] wife at the time of the murder, testified that one night in 1981 when Carper was visiting at their residence, she overheard [Small] say to Carper “I killed a girl․ [We] hit her over the head, dumped her ass in the woods and left her there.” She also testified that on one occasion when she was reading a newspaper article about the murder, [Small] walked by and said, “that’s the girl we killed.”

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/pa-supreme-court/1107623.html

Michael Singley Pennsylvania Death Row

Michael Singley was sentenced to death by the State of Pennsylvania for a double murder. According to court documents Michael Singley would sexually assault and murder his cousins wife. When a neighbor confronted him Michael Singley would murder him as well. Michael Singley would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death

Michael Singley 2022 Information

Parole Number: 302DL
Age: 45
Date of Birth: 04/01/1976
Race/Ethnicity: WHITE
Height: 6′ 02″
Gender: MALE
Citizenship: USA
Complexion: LIGHT
Current Location: PHOENIX

Michael Singley More News

The record reveals that on November 3, 1998, Appellant Michael B. Singley purchased three rolls of duct tape, ammunition for a .44 Magnum handgun, a folding lock-blade hunting knife and camouflage hunting gloves at retail stores in or around Chambersburg, Pennsylvania. He then drove to the neighborhood where his cousin, Travis Rohrer, lived with his wife, Christine Rohrer. Michael Singley loitered in the neighborhood, waiting for Christine’s arrival home from work. At approximately 5:45 p.m. that evening, Appellant saw Christine Rohrer’s Jeep in the driveway of the duplex where she and her husband resided. Michael Singley parked his vehicle a block away and proceeded on foot to the Rohrer residence carrying two rolls of duct tape, the gloves, hunting knife, and the ammunition for the handgun he knew that his cousin Travis Rohrer owned. Michael Singley gained entry into the Rohrer residence by feigning car trouble to Christine and asked to use the telephone to obtain assistance. Appellant indicated to Christine that the car trouble may have been the result of a malfunctioning car battery. Mrs. Rohrer then indicated that she could assist Appellant but first needed to change clothes. Once Mrs. Rohrer was upstairs, Appellant went to her room and began binding Christine Rohrer’s arms and mouth with the duct tape. Appellant went downstairs to retrieve something, and on his return upstairs, Appellant broke through the door which Christine Rohrer managed to lock in his absence. Appellant wrestled with Christine Rohrer for a time and then bound her arms to the bed frame, covered her eyes and mouth with the duct tape, leaving her nostrils exposed and bound her legs with the tape. He unbound her legs and raped Christine Rohrer. Appellant left the bedroom, smoked a cigarette in another room and then re-entered the bedroom where he repeatedly stabbed Christine Rohrer in the chest, neck and torso. She died as a result of the injuries inflicted.

Travis Rohrer returned home at about 8 p.m. that evening and found Michael Singley on the second floor brandishing both the handgun and the knife. Appellant forced Travis Rohrer into the bedroom, where Christine Rohrer’s body was covered with the bedclothes. Michael Singley pistol-whipped Travis Rohrer before ordering him to the ground. Appellant then stabbed Travis Rohrer several times in the back. A scuffle ensued, during which both Appellant and Travis Rohrer struggled for control of the handgun. Appellant wrested the gun free and shot Travis Rohrer once in the arm and once in the ribcage before going downstairs. Travis Rohrer survived the assault.

With the keys to Christine Rohrer’s Jeep in hand, Appellant exited the Rohrer residence only to come upon Deborah Hock and her fiancée, James Gilliam, who lived in the other half of the duplex where Christine and Travis Rohrer lived. Appellant raised the handgun and fatally shot Gilliam in the chest. Appellant turned the weapon on the prone Deborah Hock and fired at her. The shot missed Hock, but the muzzle blast left her with powder burns on her hand and wrist. Appellant left the scene in Christine Rohrer’s Jeep and drove through the countryside for a few hours before returning to Chambersburg. Appellant then called his girlfriend from a pay phone. Afterwards, he surreptitiously entered his parents’ home, the place where he had been residing. Chambersburg police eventually tracked Appellant to his parent’s house and, on November 4, 1998, took Appellant into custody.

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/pa-supreme-court/1079815.html