alabama death row | My Crime Library

Alonzo Burgess Alabama Death Row

Alonzo Burgess was sentenced to death by the State of Alabama for a triple murder. According to court documents Alonzo Burgess would go to the home of his ex girlfriend and would murder her and her two children who were all beaten to death with a metal bar. Alonzo Burgess would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death.

Alonzo Burgess 2021 Information

Inmate:	BURGESS, ALONZO LYDELL
AIS:	0000Z559

Institution:	HOLMAN PRISON

Alonzo Burgess More News

An Alabama death row inmate is entitled to a hearing to determine whether he is mentally retarded and not eligible for execution, a federal appeals court has ruled.

The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals ordered a federal court to conduct an evidentiary hearing on whether Alonzo Lydell Burgess is mentally retarded.

The lower court had denied Burgess’ claim that he is mentally retarded and that his execution is barred.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in June 2002, in the case Atkins vs. Virginia, that execution of the mentally retarded violates the Eighth Amendment prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment.

Burgess, 46, was convicted in 1994 of capital murder for the murders of his girlfriend, Sheila Nnodimele, 31, of Colbert County, and two of her children, Latoria Long, 14, and Alexis Nnodimele, 8. Evidence showed he beat the victims with part of a car jack. The jury recommended a sentence of life without parole by a vote of 8-4, but the judge sentenced Burgess to death.

The issue of Burgess’ mental capacity came up during his trial.

A neuropsychologist testified for the defense during the penalty phase of the trial that he conducted no intelligence testing on Burgess but had read reports from one defense expert and one state expert who found that Burgess was on the borderline of retardation. The state expert had not done a test but had estimated Burgess’ IQ in the range of 70 to 80.

In 2000, Burgess argued that his defense counsel was ineffective for failing to investigate and present evidence about his mental health. Burgess asked the state trial court for funds to hire an expert to evaluate his mental health and to give experts access to examine him in prison. The state trial court denied the requests.

The state court held an evidentiary hearing in 2002, four months before the Supreme Court issued its decision in the Atkins case. Burgess presented no evidence of his mental retardation claim because the state had denied his request for expert help, according to the federal appeals court ruling.

After the Atkins ruling, Burgess appealed again. This time the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals said there was nothing in the record indicating that Burgess met the definition of mentally retarded. The Alabama Supreme Court has defined retardation as having an IQ of 70 or below with substantial behavior deficits.

Burgess appealed to the federal district court and submitted an affidavit from a neuropsychologist who had tested Burgess and concluded “to a reasonable degree of psychological certainty” that Burgess was retarded.

The federal court refused to consider the affidavit or to grant Atkins a hearing. It also found that the state court’s determination that Burgess was not mentally retarded was not unreasonable based on the evidence.

In its ruling, issued July 30, the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed. It found that the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals erred in determining that Burgess was not mentally retarded based only on the court record, noting that the state’s expert had “estimated” Burgess’ IQ in the 70 to 80 range.

“When the record provides both realistic indications that a defendant might be mentally retarded and no concrete, verifiable IQ score, it is an unreasonable determination of the facts for the court to rely instead on an ‘estimate’ and equivocal statements to find as a fact that the defendant has an IQ between 70 and 80,” the court ruled.

“We hold that the state court’s determination that Burgess is not mentally retarded is an unreasonable determination of fact because it was based upon a combination of erroneous factual findings directly contradicted by the record and a record that was insufficient to support its conclusions,” the ruling states.

https://www.al.com/wire/2013/08/alabama_death_row_hearing_enti.html

Jimmy Davis Alabama Death Row

Jimmy Davis was sentenced to death by the State of Alabama for the murder of a store clerk during a robbery. According to court documents Jimmy Davis would shoot and kill a gas station clerk during a robbery. Jimmy Davis and a juvenile were arrested. The juvenile was sentenced to ten years in prison and Jimmy Davis was sentenced to death.

Jimmy Davis 2021 Information

Inmate:	DAVIS, JIMMY
AIS:	0000Z557

Institution:	HOLMAN PRISON

Jimmy Davis More News

Terrance Phillips, a 16-year-old black male, was charged in connection with the robbery and killing of Johnny Hazel. He pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit robbery of the Direct Oil and received a ten-year sentence. At the time of this trial, he testified he had been released on bond and had applied for probation. On March 17, 1993, Phillips attended high school and around 5:00 p.m., met the defendant, Jimmy Davis, and his cousin, Alphonso Phillips, at the Carver Recreation Center. The three males left Carver Center and walked to the Direct Oil Station at 20th and Noble Streets. He testified that Jimmy Davis possessed a chrome .25 caliber Raven [brand] pistol with a white handle. Davis stated ‘We’re going to hit Direct Gas Station’ or ‘We’re going to rob Direct Gas Station.’ Plans were discussed in the alley west of Gurnee Avenue. Phillips testified that Davis stated that ‘he had the gun and he was going to draw down on the man.’ Davis would point the gun at the station operator while Alphonso Phillips was to get the cash money. Terrance Phillips was to serve as a look-out. Terrance crossed the intersection of 20th and Noble Street to the North and proceeded up Noble Street as Alphonso Phillips and Jimmy Davis turned South on to the Direct Oil property. Terrance Phillips testified that he abandoned the criminal enterprise and continued walking north toward his house. After about a block’s walk he stated that he heard two or three gunshots; he continued walking to his house at 2307 Moore Avenue. He later left and walked to his grandmother’s home at 1711 Moore Avenue. There he encountered Jimmy Davis and Alphonso Phillips.

“Terrance Phillips stated [that] he asked Davis what had happened and that Davis said he told the attendant (Hazel) ‘Give it up, fuck-n@gger’ and that the attendant smiled or laughed. He (Davis) shot him at least twice and then he (Davis) took off. Terrance Phillips testified that on that night he wore a black coat with a Los Angles Kings emblem on the back; that Alphonso Phillips wore a blue jeans jacket and that Jimmy Davis wore a pair of black cut-off jean shorts and a dark green shirt with a hood on it.” 1

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/al-court-of-criminal-appeals/1083183.html

Christopher Barbour Alabama Death Row

Christopher Barbour was sentenced to death by the State of Alabama for the sexual assault and murder of a woman. According to court documents Christopher Barbour would break into the home of the victim who was beaten, sexually assault and stabbed to death. Christopher Barbour would set the victim on fire before robbing the home. Christopher Barbour would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death.

Christopher Barbour 2021 Information

Inmate:	BARBOUR, CHRISTOPHER D
AIS:	0000Z556

Institution:	HOLMAN PRISON

Christopher Barbour More News

The State’s evidence at Barbour’s trial tended to show that on March 21, 1992, 16-year-old William Roberts found the naked and partially burned body of his mother, Thelma Bishop Roberts, lying on the floor of her bedroom at her home on Manley Drive in Montgomery. When the body was found, there was a white plastic trash bag over her head and a knife protruding from her chest. Additionally, the jewelry that Roberts always wore was missing.

An autopsy revealed that Roberts died as a result of multiple stab wounds to the chest. Two of the wounds were inflicted with such force that the knife went all the way through Roberts’s body, piercing her back. One of the wounds pierced her left lung and another pierced her heart, causing extensive internal bleeding. In all, Roberts was stabbed nine times. Additionally, the autopsy revealed that Roberts had suffered repeated blows to her head.

Upon questioning by the police, Barbour gave a detailed account of the circumstances surrounding Roberts’s murder. He told police that on March 20, 1992, he, Chris Hester, and Mike Mitchell went to see “Koon,” a friend of Hester’s who lived on Manley Drive. After discovering that Koon was not home, the three went across the street to the Roberts’s house. Initially, everyone sat down in the living room and drank beer. Hester and Roberts started talking; however, Roberts subsequently left the living room and went to another part of the house. Shortly after Roberts left the living room, Hester also left the living room. A short while later, Barbour and Mitchell heard loud noises coming from the back of the house and went to investigate. Upon entering a bedroom, they saw that Roberts was naked and Hester was wearing only his pants. Hester struck Roberts, and Barbour and Mitchell began hitting her about the head, causing her to fall to the floor. Barbour and Mitchell held Roberts down while Hester raped her. After Hester got up and pulled on his pants, Barbour told the others that they could not leave because Roberts could identify them. Barbour went to the kitchen and got a knife; he then returned to the bedroom, where he knelt and stabbed Roberts several times. Barbour left the knife in Roberts’s body, stood up, walked to the closet, threw some clothes from the closet around her body, and set them on fire. As the three men fled the house, Barbour pulled the smoke detector off of the wall in the hallway and threw it down.

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/al-court-of-criminal-appeals/1487093.html

Michael Taylor Alabama Death Row

Michael Taylor was sentenced to death by the state of Alabama for the murder of an elderly couple during a robbery. According to court documents Michael Taylor who was absent without leave when he would enter an elderly couple home that he knew and proceeded to beat the couple to death with an iron bar before stealing a number of items from he home. Michael Taylor was arrested, convicted and sentenced to death

Michael Taylor 2021 Information

Inmate:	TAYLOR, MICHAEL SHANNON
AIS:	0000Z549

Institution:	HOLMAN PRISON

Michael Taylor More News

“On November 4, 1991, Michael Taylor, then a 19-year-old high school graduate who had returned to his hometown of Gadsden while absent without leave from the Navy, solicited a ride to the home of the Moores, an elderly couple he knew. Taylor left a duffel bag outside the house and asked Mr. Moore, who was age 83, if he could use the telephone. Once inside, Taylor pretended to make a telephone call, and then Mr. Moore asked him if he would like something to drink. Taylor said he would, and Mr. Moore got him a glass of water and a doughnut. After Taylor had eaten, Mr. Moore asked him if he would like something else. Taylor said he would, and Mr. Moore went back into the kitchen.

“Taylor then went outside and removed a metal bar from his duffel bag. Taylor followed Mr. Moore into the kitchen, and, as the man bent into the refrigerator, Taylor began to strike him about the head with the metal bar. Mr. Moore fell to the floor. Mrs. Moore, who was age 79, entered the kitchen and bent down to see what was wrong with her husband. Taylor then struck her repeatedly about the head with the metal bar. As Mr. Moore attempted to crawl away and get up, Taylor again struck him with the bar. Taylor then took Mr. Moore’s wallet, Mrs. Moore’s purse, their checkbook, and their 1986 Cadillac automobile. He drove to Birmingham, cashed several checks made out to his name for a total of about $1500, and made several clothing and jewelry purchases at the Galleria shopping mall.

“The Moores were discovered in their home by a neighbor two days after their beating. Mr. Moore was dead at that time; Mrs. Moore was then unconscious, but later died. The cause of both their deaths was severe blunt force injuries to their heads, which had fractured their skulls. Mr. Moore had been struck with the bar approximately 17 times and had 11 wounds on his head; Mrs. Moore had been struck with the bar at least 10 times.

“Taylor was arrested outside the Galleria shopping mall, after he had entered the Moores’ vehicle and attempted to drive away. Upon being returned to Gadsden, Taylor confessed to beating the Moores during the course of a robbery. It is disputed whether he stated, while giving his confession, that he had intended to kill the Moores.”

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/al-court-of-criminal-appeals/1239161.html

Wayne Travis Alabama Death Row

Wayne Travis was sentenced to death by the State of Alabama for a murder committed during a robbery. According to court documents Wayne Travis and Steven Hall would commit a robbery in which Clarene Haskew was beaten and shot multiple times inside of her home. Wayne Travis and Steven Hall would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death. Steven Hall was later resentenced to life in prison without parole.

Wayne Travis 2021 Information

Inmate:	TRAVIS, WAYNE HOLLEMAN
AIS:	0000Z548

Institution:	HOLMAN PRISON

Wayne Travis More News

“On the morning of December 15, 1991, Conecuh County sheriff deputies and other investigators found the body of Clarene Haskew in her home. Mrs. Haskew was a sixty-nine year old widow in poor health. Her home had been burglarized. Items were thrown about in the home. The body of Mrs. Haskew was found in the kitchen. A pentagram had been spray-painted on a cabinet above her body, the words ‘thunder struck’ spray painted in large letters on the floor beside her body. On top of her body was found a large metal hook and a set of keys. Missing from the home was silverware and an address book. Also missing was her gray 1982 Ford LTD. It was ordinarily parked outside her home. A Ford pickup parked in a shed next to the house was found with its steering column opened and wires pulled out. Two sets of keys were found in the yard.

“Dr. George Wanger, state pathologist, was called to the scene. Based upon his examination there, and a later autopsy, he determined that Mrs. Haskew had suffered two gunshot wounds to the back of the head; exit wounds were on her forehead. Two spent bullets were found near the victim’s head on the floor. He also found that she had suffered a number of blunt force injuries and had been strangled by hand or with an object. Her hyoid bone was broken and there were bruises around her throat. On her right and left cheeks were pinpoint hemorrhages. These occurred during strangulation, while her heart was beating. The muscles on her neck were bruised, a yellow abrasion on her neck occurred after there was no blood flow. The other blunt force injuries included a rectangular abrasion in the mastoid area and a tear in the skin at the right ear. The victim had numerous bruises. Red bruises were on her right lower back, blue bruises were on her buttocks, and purple bruises were on her left forearm.

“Dr. Wanger found that Mrs. Clarene Haskew died of blunt force injuries and two gunshot wounds to the head. The blunt force injuries could have been sufficient in themselves to cause death. The order of the injuries is not completely known. If the gunshot wounds were last, they would have been the cause of her death, but she could have died from the blunt force injuries if she had not been shot. The blunt force could have caused her asphyxiation after the gunshot wounds. The two gunshot wounds would have caused immediate unconsciousness and the victim probably could not have felt pain after them.

“The Defendant TRAVIS and HALL were seen early Sunday morning, December 15, 1991, at the residence of Paula Shiver in south Monroe County. They drove up in Mrs. Haskew’s 1982 Ford LTD and hid it behind a camper between 4:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m. that morning. Neither appeared out of the ordinary. Hall stayed in the house with Paula Shiver and went with her later that day to get her son. Travis stayed in the car most of the day. Defendant TRAVIS told Paula Shiver that the car was his sister-in-law’s car. Defendant TRAVIS came into the house about 6:00 p.m. that night. Monroe County Sheriff, Tom Tate, came later that evening. Paula Shiver called out that the sheriff was there. Both Defendant Travis and Hall went out the back door into the woods.

“Dog Wardens from Fountain prison came there with beagles. They tracked the Defendant TRAVIS and HALL about one and one-half miles through the woods to a kudzu patch. They shouted to Defendant TRAVIS and HALL to ‘Lay ‘em down, lay ‘em down,’ [and] one of the two suspects said ‘Lets get it on. [T]he dog wardens shot 9 or 10 times. Defendant TRAVIS and HALL were both wounded.

“Defendant Wayne TRAVIS was searched there. Found on him were the keys to Mrs. Haskew’s car, five .38 caliber bullets and his driver’s license. Mrs. Haskew’s car was impounded and searched. In the glove compartment of the car was the .38 caliber Rossi revolver taken from the Shad residence. In the trunk of the car was a .410 [gauge shot] gun, a box of silverware belonging to the victim and an address book belonging to the victim.

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/al-court-of-criminal-appeals/1003647.html