Michael Gallegos Arizona Death Row

michael gallegos arizona death row

Michael Gallegos was sentenced to death by the State of Arizona for the murder of a child. According to court documents Michael Gallegos would suffocate his step niece Kindall Wishon and after the eight year old girl was dead she was sexually assaulted. Michael Gallegos was arrested, convicted and sentenced to death.

Arizona Death Row Inmate List

Michael Gallegos 2021 Information

ASPC Florence, Central Unit
PO Box 8200
MICHAEL S. GALLEGOS 085586
Florence, AZ 85132
United States

Michael Gallegos More News

On March 16, 1990, Michael Steven Gallegos killed his 8 year old step-niece Kindall Wishon by holding his hand over her mouth and nose causing her to suffocate while he sexually assaulted her. After she died he then proceeded to have anal intercourse with her body while in her bedroom in Phoenix. He told police he went ahead and finished the act after she was dead because it wasn’t like she was going to tell anybody. The PSI mentions an accomplice named George Smallwood, but the County Attorney chose not to prosecute him for lack of evidence. Michael Gallegos was also convicted on May 24, 1991 of the following: Maricopa County CR 90-03339 – Count 2 Sexual Conduct with a Minor, committed on 3/16/90, sentenced to 21 years flat, consecutive to Count 1.

Michael Gallegos Other News

A federal appeals court ordered a lower court to consider whether an Arizona death row inmate’s trial for the 1990 sex assault and murder of an 8-year-old girl may have been tainted by the actions of a detective.

A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected all of Michael Gallegos’ claims that he was poorly represented by his attorney at his trial and at sentencing in the death of Kendall Wishon.

But the divided panel said a federal district judge should consider whether Gallegos can raise a new argument in state court that Armando Saldate, a Phoenix police detective, failed to advise him of his rights before he confessed to Wishon’s murder.

Gallegos said in court documents that Saldate “had a history of both lying in judicial proceedings and ignoring defendants’ constitutional rights,” facts that prosecutors knew but failed to tell the defense.

Prosecutors did not respond to requests to comment on the decision. But an attorney for Gallegos welcomed the court’s order, which was handed down Thursday.

“We look forward to the opportunity to present to the state court for its consideration,” said Dale Baich, a lawyer in Federal Public Defender’s Office representing Gallegos.

The case began in March 1990 when Gallegos, a Flagstaff native, and George Smallwood went to visit family living in Phoenix – Gallegos’ brother and Smallwood’s mother, who were living together with Smallwood’s younger half-sister, Kendall.

After a night of drinking while working on a car with Gallegos’ brother, Michael Gallegos suggested to Smallwood that they “fondle” Kendall. She was 8, while Gallegos and Smallwood were both high school seniors at the time.

Smallwood agreed and they sneaked into Kendall’s room. But after she began to wake, they covered her mouth and nose and she eventually stopped moving. Thinking she was dead Smallwood suggested they “finish her off,” according to court documents. Though Smallwood was unsuccessful, Gallegos had intercourse with her corpse, the opinion said.

The two carried her body outside and left it under the tree where it was found the next day, no more than 250 feet from the house. Suspicion turned to Gallegos and Smallwood after police realized that there were no signs of forced entry to the house.

After his arrest, Gallegos initially denied the crime but eventually confessed and implicated Smallwood, who denied any involvement.

Both were charged. But charges against Smallwood were dismissed after DNA testing linked Gallegos to the body, but found that Smallwood “could not be included as a contributor to the evidence.”

Gallegos was convicted in May 1991 in Maricopa County with murder and sexual conduct with a minor.

In his latest appeal, he claimed that his trial attorney, Greg Clark, did a poor job representing him, that he treated Gallegos harshly on the stand when he testified in his own defense and that he failed to adequately prepare to challenge the state’s medical expert.

But the court rejected all those claims, noting that Clark had the “exceedingly difficult task” of crafting a defense in the face of “compelling physical evidence” that his client had committed a heinous crime.

Clark told jurors at the outset that though his client was “absolutely responsible” for the crimes, he was still a “scared teenager” who “never intended to kill Kendall,” often referring to Gallegos as a “man-child.”

A second line of defense was the technical argument that Kendal was not alive at the time of the sexual assault and therefore no longer a “person” – a defense that Judge Marsha Berzon wrote in the circuit court opinion was “convoluted, inherently repulsive, and unsympathetic.”

Still, she wrote, that “novel, if disturbing” defense against felony murder may have been Clark’s best option. It was not an argument “certain to lose,” Berzon wrote, upholding the lower court’s decision to reject Gallegos’ claim of ineffective assistance of counsel.

“It would not have been unreasonable for the state court to hold that any deficiencies committed by Clark during the guilt phase did not prejudice Gallegos at the penalty stage,”

https://www.azfamily.com/az-death-row-inmate-gets-new-hearing-because-of-detectives-actions/article_5b98af7b-683f-5c65-866f-e2d58e383a75.html

Mike Gallardo Arizona Death Row

Mike Gallardo arizona death row

Mike Gallardo was sentenced to death by the State of Arizona for the murder of a college student. According to court documents Mike Gallardo broke into a home thinking no one was home however when he was surprise by Rudy Padilla he would react violently and shot dead the college student. Mike Gallardo would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death.

Arizona Death Row Inmate List

Mike Gallardo 2021 Information

ASPC Florence, Central Unit
PO Box 8200
MIKE P. GALLARDO 036366
Florence, AZ 85132
United States

Mike Gallardo More News

Mike Peter Gallardo was sentenced to death for the 2005 murder of 20-year-old college student Rudy Padilla. On the early afternoon of December 9, 2005, Gallardo called the Padilla residence but no one answered the phone. Gallardo assumed there was no one at the residence and broke the arcadia door with a lawn chair. At some point shortly after entering the residence, Rudy confronted Gallardo and a struggle ensued. Rudy’s father came home from work around 3:00 p.m. and found Rudy shot to death and with electrical cords bound on his feet, hands, and neck. Phone records proved the phone call to the Padilla residence on that day came from Gallardo’s cell phone. Gallardo’s DNA was found on blood on the lawn chair used to break the arcadia door and also on a cigarette butt found near the side gate of the residence. He was convicted of first-degree murder and first-degree burglary and kidnapping.

Mike Gallardo Other News

John Fitzgerald Arizona Death Row

john fitzgerald arizona death row

John Fitzgerald was sentenced to death by the State of Arizona for the murder of his mother. According to court documents John Fitzgerald arranged a ride to his mother’s home with her fiance as he wanted his visit to be a surprise. When they reached Margaret Larkin home an she opened the door John Fitzgerald pulled out of a samurai sword and struck his mother several times, the victim did not die so Fitzgerald pulled out a gun and shot her twice in the head. John Fitzgerald was arrested several blocks away from the murder scene. He would be convicted and sentenced to death.

Arizona Death Row Inmate List

John Fitzgerald 2021 Information

ASPC Eyman, Browning Unit
PO Box 3400
JOHN V. FITZGERALD 256148
Florence, AZ 85132
United States

John Fitzgerald More News

On the evening of April 15, 2005, John Fitzgerald was picked up at a Budget Suites Motel by his mother’s fiancé, James Totten. Fitzgerald had traveled to Arizona from Hawaii, where he was residing at the time. Weeks before, Fitzgerald had called and told James that he wanted to give his mother a surprise visit and requested a ride to her house, which James agreed to. When they arrived at the house and walked to the front door, James noticed what appeared to be a samurai sword in Fitzgerald’s hands; James had not seen the sword during the drive to the house. When Margaret came to the door Fitzgerald immediately began striking her several times with the sword. As she fell to the floor, Fitzgerald somehow lost control of the sword, pulled out his gun, and fatally shot his mother, Margaret Larkin, twice in the head and walked out the front door. Police were called immediately after and Fitzgerald was arrested without incident while walking on a street a few blocks away from the scene.

John Fitzgerald Other News

The Arizona Supreme Court on Friday unanimously upheld the convictions and sentences of a death row inmate from Hawaii in the killing of his mother in Arizona.

John Fitzgerald was convicted of killing Margaret Larkin in her Sun City West home on April 15, 2005, the day he traveled to Arizona from Hawaii.

Larkin was a recently retired nursing professor at Glendale Community College.

A Maricopa County Superior Court jury rejected Fitzgerald’s insanity defense and convicted him of first-degree murder and burglary.

A mistrial during the penalty phase of the case resulted in the impaneling of a second jury for sentencing.

The second jury sentenced John Fitzgerald to death on the murder conviction.

A judge sentenced Fitzgerald to 10.5 years in prison on the burglary conviction.

https://tucson.com/news/state-and-regional/arizona-court-turns-down-death-row-inmate-s-appeal/article_18a76e84-ca21-11e2-933a-001a4bcf887a.html

Charles Ellison Arizona Death Row

Charles Ellison arizona death row

Charles Ellison was sentenced to death by the State of Arizona for the murder of a couple. According to court documents Charles Ellison and Richard Finch broke into a home and killed the residents, Joseph and Lillian Boucher. Charles Ellison and Richard Fitch were arrested soon after. Richard Finch would plead guilty to the double murder and was sentenced to life. Charles Ellison was convicted at trial and sentenced to death

Arizona Death Row Inmate List

Charles Ellison 2021 Information

ASPC Florence, Central Unit
PO Box 8200
CHARLES D. ELLISON 057713
Florence, AZ 85132
United States

Charles Ellison More News

On February 24, 1999, Charles Ellison and Richard Finch broke into the home of Joseph and Lillian Boucher. Ellison and Finch bound the Bouchers with telephone cords and masking tape. Ellison suffocated Joseph Boucher to death with a pillow. While Ellison struggled with Joseph Boucher, Richard Finch choked Lillian Boucher to death with his hands.

Charles Ellison Other News

On the morning of February 26, 1999, police went to the home of Joseph and Lillian Boucher after their daughter, Vivian Brown, could not contact her parents.   When no one answered the door, police entered the home through the kitchen, where they noticed a telephone with its line cut and cord missing and a knife block with a missing knife.

¶ 3 Police discovered the body of Joseph Boucher on a bed in a bedroom.   He had defensive wounds and minor cuts and scrapes on his wrists and arms indicating he had been bound.   In another bedroom, police found Lillian Boucher’s body on the floor.   She had bruises on her face and body, consistent with an altercation, and a small amount of blood around her nose.   According to the medical examiner, Mr. Boucher had been asphyxiated by smothering.   Mrs. Boucher had been asphyxiated by smothering or a combination of smothering and strangulation.   Missing from the house were a .22 caliber handgun, a pellet gun, Mr. Boucher’s wedding ring and watch, and Mrs. Boucher’s diamond wedding ring, anniversary ring, watch, earrings, and crucifix.

¶ 4 On February 26, 1999, Brad Howe contacted police with information that he had obtained from Richard Finch about the murders.   Finch worked for Howe and his father as a “lot boy” at their auto dealership in Lake Havasu City and also lived at Howe’s house.   According to Howe, Finch was “simple” and, because he could not manage his own finances, Howe and his father gave Finch money only as he needed it.

¶ 5 Howe did not see Finch on the night of February 24;  however, they went drinking at several bars the next night.   Howe offered to pay as usual, but Finch surprised him by offering to buy drinks and displaying $250 to $300.   Howe told police that Finch was drinking heavily and acting as if something was on his mind.   Howe repeatedly asked Finch what was distracting him.   Finch became “very upset” and admitted he had been involved in “some bad things.”   The two then left the bar and, on the way home, Finch told Howe more details.

¶ 6 Once at home, Finch, upset and crying, retrieved a bag and showed Howe the contents.   Howe, not wanting the items in his house, took the bag and hid it in the desert in the early morning hours of February 26.   He later led police to the bag, which contained several items stolen from the Bouchers’ home.

¶ 7 The same day, police officers went to Howe’s house and arrested Finch, who had packed his belongings as if planning to leave.   After being advised of his Miranda rights, Finch agreed to speak with police.   In a taped interview, Finch confessed his involvement in the murders.   He also identified his companion as “Slinger,” a nickname used by Ellison.   Two days later, Finch helped police find the missing kitchen knife in a field behind the Bouchers’ house.

¶ 8 On March 1, 1999, after unsuccessfully searching for Ellison at the house of his girlfriend, Cathie Webster-Hauver, Kingman detectives Steven Auld and Lyman Watson learned that Ellison had been arrested in Lake Havasu.   After informing Ellison of his Miranda rights, the detectives interviewed him at the Lake Havasu police station just before 9:00 a.m. Ellison told the detectives he had met Finch two or three weeks earlier at Darby’s, a Lake Havasu bar.   The two men met again at Darby’s on February 24, 1999, where Ellison agreed to do “a job” with Finch in Kingman.   Ellison said that he intended only to commit a burglary, not to kill anyone.   Ellison also denied killing either victim.

¶ 9 That same night, Ellison and Finch drove Ellison’s van to Kingman, where they stopped at the Sundowner’s Bar. According to the bartender, Jeannette Avila, Ellison entered the bar first, ordered and paid for beers, talked to her at length, and led the way when the two men left the bar.   Finch, in contrast, never spoke to Avila;  he simply sat without removing his sunglasses.   Avila later identified Ellison in a photographic line-up, but was unable to identify Finch.

¶ 10 Ellison said they next drove to a nearby movie theater and parked the van.   Finch led the way to the Bouchers’ house and entered first.   Once inside, Ellison and Finch ordered Mrs. Boucher from the living room and into Mr. Boucher’s bedroom.   Ellison admitted binding the victims with the phone cords and masking tape, but claimed to have done so only at Finch’s direction.   Ellison said Finch then pointed a gun at him and ordered him to kill Mr. Boucher.   By his account, Ellison held a pillow over Mr. Boucher’s face for a period of time, possibly only a few seconds, while Finch strangled Mrs. Boucher.   Ellison said he removed the pillow when Mr. Boucher stopped struggling, but claimed he thought Mr. Boucher was still alive because his chest was moving up and down.   Ellison said he told Finch he would have to finish off Mr. Boucher.   Ellison also said that after Finch strangled Mrs. Boucher, Finch moved her body to another bedroom.

¶ 11 Ellison claimed that it was Finch’s idea to “hit” the house and that he did not know how Finch had picked the Bouchers’ home.   Ellison admitted he was somewhat familiar with the area because his parents lived nearby.   Additionally, at trial, Brown identified Ellison as having worked on her parents’ home in October 1997 and at a nearby house the next year.   According to Howe, Finch did not possess a gun or a vehicle and had never gone to Kingman before February 24, 1999.

¶ 12 The police acknowledged at trial that no physical evidence proved who actually killed either victim.   None of the approximately 170 fingerprints found in the house matched Ellison or Finch.   Police found a latex glove in the Bouchers’ yard.   Ellison later admitted he had supplied the latex gloves that he and Finch wore during the burglary and murders.   None of the Bouchers’ property was found on Ellison, in his van, or at his girlfriend’s home.   Ellison, however, was not arrested until five days after the murders.   Ellison admitted removing jewelry from Mrs. Boucher’s body, but said he did so only at Finch’s direction.   He also admitted using twenty dollars stolen from the Bouchers to buy gas for his van.

¶ 13 The detectives attempted to record their initial interview with Ellison but failed to do so.2  Detective Watson re-interviewed Ellison at 10:06 a.m. In this nine-minute recorded interview, Detective Watson tried to summarize the main points of the first interview.   This tape was played for the guilt proceeding jury.

¶ 14 On March 4, 1999, Ellison and Finch were indicted for the murders and first degree burglary.   The State sought the death penalty for each defendant.   Judge Robert R. Moon severed their trials.   In September 2000, a jury convicted Finch on the murder and burglary charges.   In March 2001, Judge Moon sentenced Finch to natural life imprisonment, finding, among other things, mitigating factors due to Finch’s having acted under duress from Ellison and later cooperating with police in the investigation.

¶ 15 Ellison was tried in January 2002.   With Judge Moon presiding, the jury convicted Ellison on the murder and burglary charges, specifically finding him guilty of both premeditated and felony murder of the Bouchers and that he had either killed, intended to kill, or acted with reckless indifference.

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/az-supreme-court/1103798.html

Eugene Doerr Arizona Death Row

eugene doerr arizona death row

Eugene Doerr was sentenced to death by the State of Arizona for the murder of a woman. According to court documents Eugene Doerr would call the police and report a dead woman inside of his house. When police arrived they found the victim, Karen Bohl, naked with a ton of brutal injuries to her body. Authorities would later determine that she had died from blunt force injuries. Eugene Doerr would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death.

Arizona Death Row Inmate List

Eugene Doerr 2021 Information

ASPC Florence, Central Unit
PO Box 8200
EUGENE A. DOERR 125421
Florence, AZ 85132
United States

Eugene Doerr More News

On September 24, 1994, Eugene Doerr called police. He reported waking up and finding a dead woman in his bedroom. The nude victim, Karen Bohl, was found lying on the floor with several lacerations to her head. A nipple had been cut off her breast. She suffered major trauma to her vagina and rectal area. Bruises and abrasions were found on her neck and other parts of her body. Investigators noticed signs of a major struggle inside the apartment, including bloodstains on walls, floors and furniture in different rooms. An autopsy later revealed Karen Bohl died from multiple blunt force trauma. Eugene Doerr’s clothes and most of his body were covered in dried blood. When his clothing was removed, investigators observed his pelvic area and penis were also saturated with dried blood. He had several injuries, including a broken hand, a deep laceration to his wrist consistent with a knife wound. A bloody steak knife was found on the bathroom sink. A bloodstained brass pipe was located on the living room floor. Eugene Doerr told police he had gone out drinking at a couple of bars the previous evening, and did not remember coming home. When he woke up, he found the victim’s body and realized he was covered with blood. He claimed he had no idea what happened. The defendant informed an investigator the victim’s purse was on the bathroom floor and her car was parked out front. He then tried to correct himself by saying he believed the car was hers. Doerr stated, “She must have really made me mad for me to do something to her like this. ” He asked an officer if he would be getting life in prison for the crime, then declined to answer questions without an attorney. Blood samples taken from Eugene Doerr showed no presence of drugs or alcohol.

Eugene Doerr Other News

At approximately 10:00 a.m. on September 24, 1994, two Phoenix police officers responded to a “check welfare” dispatch following a 911 call. Upon arriving at a bungalow-style apartment, they found the front door ajar and a disheveled Eugene Doerr sitting on the coffee table in the living room. He wore only shorts and was covered with blood.

When asked what had occurred, Doerr replied: “I don’t know. I woke up with this—with a dead body back there.” In a bedroom doorway, Officer Wirth found a naked woman lying in a pool of blood. Detecting no pulse, he instructed his partner to radio the fire department. Doerr responded, “[Y]ou don’t need fire because she’s dead.” He told the officers that he had awakened, gone to the bathroom, and found the body on the floor. He denied knowing the victim’s identity.

The four-room apartment showed signs of a violent struggle, with blood in every room. At trial, the medical examiner testified that the victim, 39-year-old Karen Bohl, died of multiple blunt force trauma. She suffered numerous injuries to the head, including a fractured nose, abrasions, cuts, bruises, and a two-inch laceration that exposed her skull. Her left hand was swollen and red. Her right hand was clenched in a fist holding hairs consistent with her own. Her left nipple and areola had been cut off, and above her right nipple were small lacerations. The body was covered in blood and fecal matter. Blood also formed a V-shaped pattern down her back from saturated hair.

The victim had been assaulted vaginally and rectally with an instrument of some kind. The doctor testified that the wall between her rectum and cervix had been destroyed. A bloody pipe, apparently part of a broken lampstand, and a bloody broom handle were found nearby—objects that the medical examiner said could have produced the injuries. Because of significant blood loss, swelling, and bruising, the doctor concluded that the injuries likely occurred prior to or during the victim’s death. There were twenty-six other areas of injury to her body. Her blood alcohol level tested at .25, but no other drugs were detected. Tests for semen were negative.

Defendant Doerr was also injured. His right hand was swollen, and he had minor cuts on his forearm, above his wrist, and on his left foot. His chest, stomach, pubic area, and hands were smeared and caked with blood.
. . . .

Defendant first claimed that he had no idea how the woman got there. Later, as officers waited for a search warrant, he told them that he thought her purse and ID were in the bathroom “because I remember seeing a purse and I don’t own a purse.” He also said the white car parked out front belonged to the victim. “That is her car she said . . . I think.” One of the officers testified that Doerr hesitated before adding the “I think.”

Doerr voluntarily went to the police station. During questioning, he asked one of the officers if he thought a judge would give him life for the murder. He also said, “[S]he must have really made me mad for me to do something to her like this.” The police did not test Doerr for drugs or alcohol until about 3:00 p.m., five hours after the 911 call. The tests were negative.

https://casetext.com/case/doerr-v-shinn