Michael Pilato Teen Killer Fatal Fire

michael pilato photos

Michael Pilato was a fourteen year old from New York State that would set his family home on fire killing three people. According to court documents Michael Pilato would pour gasoline all over the New York home before lighting it on fire killing his 71-year-old father, Carmen, and brothers,  16-year-old Peter and 12-year-old Josh. Thankfully his mother and sister were able to escape the fire. This teen killer would be sentenced to fifteen years to life.

Michael Pilato 2023 Information

DIN (Department Identification Number)17B1968  
Date of Birth07/04/1996  
Race / EthnicityWHITE  
Custody StatusIN CUSTODY  
Housing / Releasing FacilityCAYUGA  
Date Received (Original)07/06/2017  
Date Received (Current)07/06/2017  
Admission TypeNEW COMMITMENT  
County of CommitmentMONROE  
Latest Release Date / Type (Released Inmates Only)
Aggregate Minimum Sentence0015 Years, 00 Months, 00 Days
Aggregate Maximum SentenceLIFE Years, 99 Months, 99 Days
Earliest Release Date12/03/2026  
Parole Hearing Date08/2026  
Parole Eligibility Date12/03/2026  
Conditional Release DateNONE  
Maximum Expiration DateLIFE  

Michael Pilato More News

A teenager convicted of setting a fire that killed his father and two brothers inside their western New York home has been sentenced to 15 years to life in prison.

Local media outlets report that 16-year-old Michael Pilato was sentenced Wednesday in Monroe County Court in Rochester but didn’t comment.

Pilato was convicted last month of second-degree murder, attempted murder, murder by arson and arson. Police say he poured gasoline throughout his Webster home and set it ablaze in December 2011, killing his 71-year-old father, Carmen, and brothers,  16-year-old Peter and 12-year-old Josh.

Pilato’s mother and a 13-year-old sister escaped the fire with injuries.

A defense lawyer argued Pilato was experiencing “extreme emotional disturbance” when he set the fire.

District Attorney Sandra Doorley reportedly said the boy’s actions were diabolical and there was worry he would kill again if set free.

According to CBS affiliate WROC, Elaine Pilato, Michael’s mother, said, “He’s a good living son of 15 years who just snapped that night, for which he doesn’t need to spend his life in jail. Everyone deserves a second chance. I have a lot of guilt because parents are supposed to save their children.”

Elaine supported her son through the trial and says he didn’t purposely set the fire.

Monroe County Court Judge Vincent Dinolfo said he would have given the teen a stronger sentence if the law had allowed it, according to WROC.


Michael Pilato Videos

Michael Pilato FAQ

Michael Pilato Now

Michael Pilato is currently incarcerated at the Cayuga Facility

Michael Pilato Release Date

Michael Pilato is serving a life sentence however is eligible for parole in 2026
author avatar

1 thought on “Michael Pilato Teen Killer Fatal Fire”

  1. I’m sorry but I don’t think after what he did should be paroled because his step sisters have had to deal with losing not just there dad but 2 brothers and they have had went through so much pain and trauma from it and I also lost a real brother that day Peter pilato was my real brother that I never got to meet because he was adopted and I didn’t find him till a few days after this happen I have always wanted to find my brother so never getting to ever meet him kinda hurt I am part of his family now Peters sister Jen is like my sister now even though we are not blood after losing Peter and I connected with her and her family I became part of there life Peters sister Jen was my brides maid even

    I’m sorry but the pain and suffering Jen has gone through since she lost her dad and 2 brothers …. Michel should not be allowed for parole anytime soon he took a life or should I say 3 lives deliberately he poured gas all the way through house by all doors and all the way down stairs to the door then lite house on fire that was no accident that’s premeditated I’m sorry please don’t let him out


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top