Timothy Buss was a twelve year old teen killer from Illinois that would murder a five year old girl and when he was released from prison would murder a ten year old boy. According to court documents Timothy Buss was a twelve year old boy when he would murder Tara Sue Huffman of Bradley who was five years old in 1981. Timothy Buss would be convicted and sentenced to spend 25 years in prison however he would later be paroled in 1993
In 1996 Timothy Buss would murder Christopher Meyer of Aroma Park who was ten years old. For the second murder Timothy Buss would be sentenced to death however his sentence would later be commuted to life in prison.
Timothy Buss 2023 Information
| Parent Institution: | STATEVILLE CORRECTIONAL CENTER |
| Offender Status: | IN CUSTODY |
| Location: | STATEVILLE |
Timothy Buss More News
Timothy Buss, convicted of the murder of two Kankakee County children, was back in court Tuesday seeking to shorten his prison time.
Buss was convicted in 1996 for the death of 10-year-old Christopher Meyer of Aroma Park and in 1981 for killing 5-year-old Tara Sue Huffman of Bradley. Buss was on parole from the first murder conviction when the second murder occurred.
Meyer’s body was discovered in a shallow grave in Kankakee River State Park’s Hunting Area 7, just inside the Will County Line. He’d been stabbed 48 times.
Before leaving office in January, former Gov. George Ryan of Kankakee reduced Buss’ sentence for the Meyer murder from death by lethal injection to life imprisonment.
Ryan’s action also opened the door to Buss’ attempt to shorten his prison time and that’s just what his lawyers were attempting to achieve Tuesday in Will County Circuit Court.
This time their case will focus on the car he owned in 1995. Buss claims, among other things, that police searched the car without permission.
A 1999 bid to evade the death penalty for the Meyer murder failed when the Illinois Supreme Court rejected Buss’ claim that he should be spared execution because the state failed to adequately treat the mental illness that occasioned his killing of Tara Sue Huffman.
He also claims that additional issues related to the case have yet to be presented and that he did not voluntarily give police permission to search his home during the Meyer murder investigation.
Buss’ next court appearance will be 9:30 a.m., June 9.
Timothy Buss Videos
Timothy Buss Legal
At Timothy Buss 1996 trial, Mika Moulton, Christopher Meyer’s mother, testified that, in August 1995, she and her children lived in Aroma Park, Illinois. During the afternoon of August 7, 1995, she gave 10½-year-old Christopher permission to go to the Aroma Park boat launch on the Kankakee River. Moulton instructed Christopher to return home at 5 p.m. that day. When he left on his bicycle for the boat launch, Christopher was wearing blue shorts, a green patterned T-shirt, Chicago Blackhawks high-top tennis shoes, and Ninja Turtle underwear. When Christopher did not return home that evening, Moulton looked for him without success. She notified police, who began a search for Christopher.
In the days following Christopher’s disappearance, members of the team searching for him found Christopher’s clothing and bicycle in areas around the Kankakee River. Searchers testified that, while dragging the river on August 8, they found one of Christopher’s shoes floating near the Aroma Park boat launch. That same day, searchers found the bicycle Christopher was last seen riding. The bicycle was recovered across the river from the boat launch in a wooded area east of the railroad trestle on Birchwood Drive.
During the morning of August 9, 1995, Christopher’s other shoe was found floating in the Kankakee River near the Kankakee Country Club, which is downstream from the Aroma Park boat launch. On August 12, searchers found pieces of Christopher’s clothing in the area around the gravel parking lot for Hunting Area 10 in the Kankakee State Park. On a path leading from the parking lot, there was a piece of Christopher’s T-shirt on the ground, and a pair of Ninja Turtle underwear was hanging in a nearby bush.
While the search for Christopher proceeded, police learned that several individuals had seen Christopher and a man resembling defendant at the boat launch during the afternoon of August 7. Jacob Mailloux, who was 14 years old at the time of trial, testified that he went to the boat launch with his friend Paul Buckner during the afternoon of August 7. As he and Buckner fished at the bayou, an area adjacent to the boat launch, Mailloux saw Christopher talking to a man. Mailloux knew Christopher because he had seen him at the boat launch before. The man with Christopher had dark hair and a mustache and was wearing a turquoise tank top and blue jean cut-off shorts.
During a conversation Mailloux had with this man, the man said that he had been raised in Aroma Park, had family in the area, and had just returned from Florida. The man also talked to Mailloux about salt water fishing in Florida. Mailloux noticed that the man’s tackle box contained a filet knife and lures that were too big to be used by fishermen in the Aroma Park area. Although Mailloux was unable to make a positive identification of defendant in court or at the lineup he viewed, he testified that defendant was similar to the man he saw with Christopher.
Fifteen-year-old Edward Meier testified that, around 4 p.m. on August 7, 1995, he was at the boat launch with his friends Dustin and Darren Posing. Meier saw Christopher walk out of the woods on a path leading from the fishing area adjacent to the boat launch. Christopher walked to a car, where he spoke to someone, after which he jogged to the boat ramp to wash mud from his shoes in the river. He then retrieved his bike, which was leaning on a nearby tree.
Darren suggested that Christopher ride his bike into the river but Christopher refused, saying he had to be home by 4:30 p.m. Dustin told him it was only 4:17 p.m., but Christopher replied that he had to leave. Meanwhile, the car slowly circled around the parking lot and then drove out of the lot toward Harry’s Bait Shop. Christopher quickly rode out of the parking lot after the car. On August 10, 1995, Meier selected defendant’s car from 25 or 30 cars in the parking lot of the Kankakee County sheriff’s department and identified it as the car he saw at the boat launch on August 7.
Darren Posing’s testimony was essentially the same as Meier’s, except that he did not see Christopher talking to anyone at the boat launch. Posing, who was 12 years old at the time of trial, did, however, see one car in the boat launch parking lot, a gray or dark blue car that appeared to be a 1984 Oldsmobile Ciera. He told police that defendant’s car was similar to the one he saw at the boat launch. In addition, he testified that Christopher rode toward Harry’s Bait Shop when he left the parking lot of the boat launch.
Beth Waselewski testified that she was at the Aroma Park boat launch with her boyfriend, Jason Forbes, on August 7, 1995. She saw Christopher pushing his bike and following a man in his late thirties or early forties. The man wore a dark sleeveless shirt, had a mustache, had dark hair, and was smoking a cigarette. Christopher and this man were walking out of the woods on the path leading from the bayou. Waselewski saw a dark gray four-door car in the parking lot of the boat launch but was unable to tell members of the Kankakee County sheriff’s department whether the car she saw at the boat launch was among the cars she later viewed in the parking lot of the department. She was also unable to tell whether the man she saw with Christopher was in a lineup she viewed, but she testified that it was “very possible” that defendant was that man, and it was “possible” that defendant’s car was the one she saw at the boat launch.
Other individuals saw Timothy Buss or Timothy Buss’s car in the Aroma Park area around August 7. Charles Henry testified that, in August 1995, he lived east of the trestle on Birchwood Drive. Across the road from his house there was a park between the road and the river.
On August 7, 1995, he was driving home from work when he saw a car in the parking area of the park. The car was parked facing him, and there was a man standing behind the car by the open trunk. As Henry drove past the park, he had a side view of the man. He made eye contact with the man when the man turned to look at him.
According to Henry, the man had dark, wavy hair and was wearing blue jeans and a gray T-shirt. Henry did not notice any facial hair on the man, but he did see a filet knife in a leather case protruding from the man’s back pocket. Henry, a fisherman, explained that it was common for fishermen to have this type of leather case and filet knife, which he described as a thin, single-edged, flexible knife. Henry could not remember whether he saw the car and the man when he came home for lunch between 12:30 and 1 p.m. or when he returned home from work between 4:30 and 5:30 p.m.
Henry reported his observations to police on August 9. On August 10, Henry viewed a group of 20 to 25 cars in the parking lot of the Kankakee County sheriff’s department. From these cars, he selected Timothy Buss’s car, which he stated looked like the car he saw on August 7. On August 11, Henry viewed a lineup, from which he identified Timothy Buss as the person he saw on August 7. Henry also made a courtroom identification of Timothy Buss.
Bobbye Fancher testified that, at 12:45 a.m. on August 7, 1995, she was driving to work on Route 113 when she saw an older model silver-blue Spectrum turn in front of her from a dirt road just west of Hunting Area 7 in the Kankakee State Park. At about 9:25 p.m. on August 8, Fancher was driving on the same route when she saw the same car turn onto Route 113 at the same location. The car did not turn on its headlights for one-half to one mile. The man driving the car had a mustache. Fancher contacted police and, after viewing a group of 23 to 35 cars at the police station, she identified the defendant’s car as the one she saw on August 7 and 8. She admitted having worked with defendant’s father at one time but stated that she was unaware that defendant had been arrested for Christopher’s murder when she contacted police about the car she saw. David Buss testified that he and Fancher had had disagreements at work but that they had last worked together 15 to 20 years ago.
According to records from the Illinois Secretary of State, Timothy Buss owned a 1986 four-door Chevy Spectrum around the time of Christopher’s murder. In June 1995, Timothy Buss obtained Illinois license plates for this car and title was transferred from Florida to Illinois.
Other testimony by some of Timothy Buss’s neighbors linked him to Christopher’s disappearance. Candace Adkins testified that, in August 1995, she lived in the same apartment building as defendant. He had moved there from Florida in May of that year.
On August 6, her sister returned a hammer that they had borrowed from Timothy Buss. The hammer was clean when they returned it to him. Around 1 p.m. on August 7, she saw Timothy Buss’s car at the apartment building, but it was gone when she looked for it around 4, 5, or 6 p.m. that day. On August 9, Timothy Buss asked Adkins if she knew where he was on Monday (August 7) and told her that he was a suspect in Christopher’s disappearance. Adkins noticed that Timothy Buss had three scratches on his forearm when she saw him on August 9.
Candace’s sister, Laura Adkins, testified that she lived with her sister in August 1995 and had seen Timothy Buss that summer with a filet knife in a case on his belt. On August 8, she saw him sitting in his car for long periods of time in a daze. He had not acted this way in the past.
Members of the Kankakee police department and Kankakee County sheriff’s department testified concerning their attempts to speak to Timothy Buss about Christopher’s disappearance. On August 9, police visited the home of David and Terry Buss, defendant’s father and stepmother. Terry Buss refused to speak to police that morning without an attorney. That afternoon, however, David Buss told police that Timothy Buss was living in Joliet with his brother.
When police visited Timothy Buss’s Joliet address that afternoon, no one was home. Timothy Buss was also not at his place of employment. Police placed defendant’s apartment under surveillance and observed him return home that evening. At around 9 p.m., police saw defendant’s car parked in front of his apartment building but, shortly thereafter, police realized that defendant’s car had disappeared. Their attempts to locate the car that night were unsuccessful.
Wanda Poole, a neighbor of defendant’s in August 1995, testified that she is familiar with Timothy Buss’s car. Around 8:40 or 9 p.m. on August 9, she was sitting in her garage when she saw Timothy Buss’s car traveling down the alley behind her home at 35 to 40 miles per hour. Although it was dark, the car’s headlights were off.
Theresa Billingsley testified that she was working as a desk manager at the B and P Motel in Braidwood on the night of August 9. A man checked into the motel at about 10 p.m. under the name of Jim Benson. The man was driving a blue-gray, older model, four-door Spectrum with fishing rods in the back window. He was smoking when he registered at the motel and was assigned a smoking room. Billingsley contacted police because she believed that this man resembled the composite sketch on a flier police had distributed regarding Christopher’s disappearance. In response to Billingsley’s call, police placed defendant under surveillance at the motel.
Marsha Pressler testified that she worked as a desk clerk at the B and P Motel during the day on August 10. At around 8:25 a.m., Timothy Buss checked out of the motel. After defendant left the motel office, Pressler saw him place a pair of boots in the motel dumpster. Pressler asked another guest at the motel to retrieve the boots from the dumpster and place them in a plastic bag. Pressler gave this bag to Braidwood police officer Keith Kemp, who testified that the boots were “water soaked” but in good condition when he received them.
Kankakee County Deputy Sheriff Brady Bertrand, the police officer assigned to watch Timothy Buss at the motel, testified that he also observed defendant place a pair of boots in the motel dumpster and then drive away from the motel in a light blue or gray Chevy Spectrum. Bertrand followed Timothy Buss to the Wilmington Dam.
William Treadman, testified that he was at the Wilmington Dam around 9 a.m. on August 10. Timothy Buss approached Treadman and asked whether Treadman had seen him fishing at the Dam before. Treadman responded that he had not.
David Buss explained at trial that, after police came to his house on August 9, he had contacted defendant and advised him to spend the night at a motel around the Wilmington Dam, speak to people at the Dam in the morning to “verify his whereabouts” on August 7, and turn himself in to police.
After Bertrand and Timothy Buss arrived at the Dam on August 10, four other officers joined Bertrand. Three of those officers, Lieutenant Gary Mitchell, Detective Rich Sims, and Lieutenant Larry Osenga, approached Timothy Buss. Mitchell identified himself and told defendant they wanted to speak to him. Defendant appeared nervous, walked in circles, and did not make eye contact with the officers. In addition, when Sims attempted to take a picture of him, defendant turned his face away and put his hands up to shield his face.
At the request of the police officers, Timothy Buss then drove his car to the sheriff’s department. Two officers accompanied defendant to the sheriff’s department in their own cars. Defendant parked his car in the parking lot of the sheriff’s department. While he was inside, police had a towing company bring other similar cars to the parking lot, after which police asked potential witnesses if they recognized any of the cars in the parking lot. That afternoon, after consulting with his attorney, Timothy Buss consented in writing to the search of his car. Defendant was arrested on August 10, 1995.
Christopher’s body was found in Will County on August 15, 1995. Will County Sheriff’s Deputy Scott Swearengen testified that he and another deputy were searching the hunting areas of the Kankakee State Park during the early morning hours of August 15. In a clearing at the end of a path leading from the parking area of Hunting Area 7, they found the body of a small child in a shallow grave under a sheet of plywood.
Forensic evidence presented by the State established that the body was that of Christopher and that he had died from multiple stab wounds prior to sunset on August 7. Dr. Edward Pavlik, an expert in forensic odontology, testified that he was asked to assist in identifying the body recovered in Hunting Area 7. Based on the development of the teeth in the body and a comparison of these teeth to photographs of Christopher’s teeth before his death, Pavlik determined that the body belonged to Christopher.
Dr. Larry Blum, an expert in forensic pathology, testified that he performed the autopsy of Christopher’s body. The body was unclothed and showed signs of decomposition. Blum found a contusion to Christopher’s jaw and 52 stab wounds and cuts on the body, primarily to the chest, abdomen, and back. In Blum’s opinion, the stab and slash wounds were made by a sharp, single-edged knife that was relatively long and narrow. This knife could have been a filet knife. There was also evidence that this type of knife had been used to cut Christopher’s genital area; his external genitalia were missing. None of Christopher’s wounds, including one stab wound to his heart and 12 to his lungs, was sufficient to cause immediate death. Blum opined that the cause of death was multiple stab wounds.
Neal Haskell, a forensic entomologist, explained that certain insects are attracted to human remains, sometimes within seconds of death, and lay their eggs in these remains. Based on the stage of development of the insects found in a corpse, a precise estimation of the time of death may be obtained. Haskell analyzed the insects recovered from Christopher’s body, as well as the environmental conditions to which the body had been subjected. He concluded that the time of death was most likely sometime before sunset on August 7.
Other forensic evidence connected Timothy Buss to Christopher’s murder. Randy Hartman, a Kankakee County police detective and evidence technician, helped process defendant’s car after defendant consented to the search. He testified that he vacuumed the car and placed the collected debris in sealed bags. On the floor of the back seat, Hartman found a bucket and hammer with mud caked on the claw. There were fishing poles in the back window and a tackle box in the trunk. There was no filet knife in this tackle box, but the box did contain various lures, sinkers, and a salt water fishing hook. There was blood on the carpet of the trunk, as well as on items in the trunk, such as a lug wrench, dent puller, and bottle.
The police also searched Timothy Buss’s apartment, as well as his room at the B and P Motel. In the motel dumpster, police found a motel receipt with the name of Jim Benson on it. No filet knife was found in the apartment or at the motel.
Ralph Meyer, a forensic microscopist for the Illinois State Police Forensic Science Lab, testified that he analyzed hairs recovered from Timothy Buss’s car and from the T-shirt fragment found in Hunting Area 10. He obtained hair samples from Christopher’s body and from defendant. He stated that the characteristics of two hairs recovered from the front passenger area of defendant’s car matched the characteristics of Christopher’s hair, which was very unique in terms of structure and pigment. Characteristics of a hair found on the T-shirt fragment also matched those of Christopher’s hair.
Kenneth Knight, a forensic scientist with the Illinois State Police Crime Lab and an expert in forensic microscopy, testified that he analyzed soil recovered from the claw of the hammer found in defendant’s car and soil from the grave site. He found that these soil samples were consistent with each other.
Robert Hunton, a forensic scientist with the Illinois State Police and an expert in foot marks testified that he compared a partial footprint found at the grave site to the boots Timothy Buss discarded at the B and P Motel. The pattern and size of the right boot was the same as the footprint.
Gail Kienast, a forensic scientist at the Illinois State Bureau of Forensic Sciences and an expert in serology and blood analysis, testified that she analyzed items recovered by police in this case. She determined that there was human blood on the dent puller found in the trunk of Timothy Buss’s car. On carpet from the trunk there was a stain of human blood that had soaked through the carpet. There was human blood on a box found at the grave site. There was also blood on the boots Timothy Buss had placed in the motel dumpster, although the test to determine whether this blood was human was not positive.
William Frank, the DNA Research Coordinator for the Illinois State Police Forensic Sciences Command and an expert in forensic DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) analysis, testified that he analyzed DNA extracted from an inhaler prescribed for Christopher, from carpet from the trunk of Timothy Buss’s car, from a piece of Christopher’s right femur, and from a bloodstained box found at the grave site. Frank used two methods of DNA analysis: PCR (polymerase chain reaction) and RFLP (restriction fragment length polymorphism). Each of these methods is used to identify particular characteristics of a given sample of DNA. Those characteristics are referred to as the “profile” of that DNA. Because each method of analysis, PCR and RFLP, identifies different characteristics, two different profiles are obtained by subjecting a sample of DNA to both types of analysis.
Frank used the PCR method to analyze DNA found on the inhaler, carpet, femur, and box. The PCR profile of the DNA from each of these items was the same. Frank calculated that this particular DNA profile could be found in one out of 19,000 Caucasian individuals.
Using the RFLP method, which is more discriminating, Frank compared the DNA in blood samples from Christopher’s parents and Timothy Buss to the DNA in blood found on the box and carpet. (Because the amount of DNA extracted from Christopher’s inhaler and femur was insufficient for the RFLP method of analysis, Frank used DNA from Christopher’s parents to determine whether the blood from the box and carpet belonged to Christopher.) By comparing the DNA profiles he obtained, Frank determined that the blood on the box and the carpet came from a child of Mika Moulton and James Meyer, Sr., Christopher’s father. Frank calculated that the chance of two Caucasian parents producing a child with the same RFLP DNA profile as the DNA found on the carpet and box was one out of 3.8 million.
Having obtained a PCR and an RFLP profile for the DNA found on the box and carpet, Frank then estimated the frequency of DNA with these both of these profiles in the population. He determined that a person with such DNA would occur in the Caucasian population only 1 out of 419 million times.
The parties stipulated that Timothy Buss was 28 years old at the time of trial.
The defense presented the testimony of three witness who believed they saw Timothy Buss around the time of Christopher’s disappearance. In an effort to show that such eyewitness identifications are unreliable, the defense then called witnesses whose testimony indicated that defendant was not the individual these three witnesses saw. For example, Kankakee County Deputy Sheriff Marcia Dillon testified that, while she was working at the search command center on August 8 at 6 a.m., she saw a man resembling the composite sketch police had distributed. The man drove into the command center parking lot in a blue-gray, early eighties model Buick, Chevy, or Oldsmobile. Dillon could not positively identify defendant as the driver and testified that Timothy Buss’s car was not the car she saw that morning.
Cindy Berglund testified that, around 1 p.m. on August 8, she was at a pond a half hour from Kankakee with her 13-year-old son, David Berglund. A man driving a silver-blue Chevy exited his car and began talking to her son. After seeing Timothy Buss’s picture in the newspaper, she believed that the man she saw talking to her son was Timothy Buss, and she contacted police. David Berglund testified that the man talked to him about fishing. Both Berglunds testified that, if the man they saw was not defendant, he was defendant’s twin. Neither Berglund, however, was able to identify the car they saw from the group of cars police showed them.
In contradiction to Dillon’s and Berglund’s testimony, Michelle Cash, one of defendant’s neighbors, testified that her children did not awaken defendant until 10 a.m. on August 8. In addition, Cash testified that, between 10:30 a.m. and 2 p.m. on August 8, defendant was with her running errands.
Like Berglund, Francis Wood testified that she was at a lake near Wilmington with her grandchildren at about 7:30 or 8:30 p.m. on August 5, 1995, when a man approached her grandson and spoke to him about fishing. He was driving an eighties model dark-gray automobile with a dent on the driver’s side. She contacted police about the incident after seeing a picture of Timothy Buss on television. She testified that she believed the man was defendant. Defendant’s father and aunt, however, testified that defendant was at his sister’s wedding and reception on August 5 from 2 to 10:30 p.m.
In addition, to rebut Fancher’s testimony that she saw Timothy Buss driving near Hunting Area 7 on the evening of August 8, defendant’s grandmother, Alice Buss, testified that defendant was with her in Kankakee that evening from 6 p.m. to 10 p.m.
Timothy Buss sought to further undermine the identifications of him by the State’s witnesses by presenting the testimony of witnesses who thought they may have seen defendant and Christopher together but who were unable to identify defendant at lineups. For example, Thomas Dellibac testified that, on August 7 at around 5:30 p.m., he saw a boy and a man fishing on the Kankakee River 50 to 100 yards downriver from the Aroma Park boat launch. The boy resembled Christopher and the man looked similar to defendant. Dellibac could not, however, positively identify anyone in the lineup police showed him.
Similarly, Steven Jones testified that, around 4:30 p.m. on August 7, 1995, he saw a man and a blond-haired boy in a car leaving a playground on the Kankakee River in Aroma Park. The car was traveling at a high rate of speed, and there was a 20-inch bicycle in the trunk. Although he first tentatively selected Timothy Buss from a lineup he saw in October 1995, he was unable to positively identify the driver of the car.
To show that Timothy Buss was not the only man in Aroma Park to have recently arrived from Florida around the time of Christopher’s murder, defendant also presented the testimony of Michael Ingalls, who testified that, around noon on August 8, he had a conversation with a man in Harry’s Bait Shop in Aroma Park. The man said that he had driven to Illinois from Florida. The man was in his late thirties to mid-forties, had black hair and a mustache, and was driving a white compact car.
After hearing this evidence, the jury found Timothy Buss guilty of all of the charges against him. The same jury found Timothy Buss eligible for the death penalty based on the following three statutory aggravating factors: (1) defendant had been convicted of murdering two or more individuals (720 ILCS 5/9-1(b)(3) (West 1994)); (2) the murder occurred in the course of a felony (720 ILCS 5/9-1(b)(6) (West 1994)); and (3) the murder victim was under the age of 12 and his death resulted from exceptional brutal or heinous behavior indicative of wanton cruelty (720 ILCS 5/9-1(b)(7) (West 1994)).
Following a hearing at which extensive testimony concerning aggravation and mitigation was presented, the jury found that there were no mitigating factors sufficient to preclude the imposition of the death penalty. The circuit court entered judgment on counts I (intentional first degree murder), VIII (aggravated kidnaping), and X (aggravated unlawful restraint) of the indictment. The court sentenced defendant to death for the first degree murder conviction and imposed sentences of 30 years’ imprisonment for the aggravated kidnaping conviction and five years’ imprisonment for the aggravated unlawful restraint conviction….
https://caselaw.findlaw.com/il-supreme-court/1008442.html
Timothy Buss Now
Timothy Buss is currently incarcerated at the Stateville Correctional Center in Illinois
Timothy Buss Release Date
Timothy Buss is serving life without parole