Allen Cox Florida Death Row

allen cox

Allen Cox was sentenced to death by the State of Florida for a prison murder. According to court documents Allen Cox was already serving a life sentence for kidnapping and sexual assault when he would murder fellow inmate Thomas Baker. According to reports someone had broken into Allen Cox footlocker and he believed it to be Thomas Baker so he would beat and stab the man to death. Allen Cox would be convicted and sentenced to death.

Florida Death Row Inmate List

Allen Cox 2021 Information

DC Number:188854
Name:COX, ALLEN W
Race:WHITE
Sex:MALE
Birth Date:09/20/1962
Initial Receipt Date:06/20/1990
Current Facility:UNION C.I.
Current Custody:MAXIMUM
Current Release Date:DEATH SENTENCE

Allen Cox More News

On December 20, 1998, the appellant discovered that someone had broken into his personal footlocker and stolen approximately $500.   Upon making this discovery, Cox walked out onto the balcony of his dorm and announced that he would give fifty dollars to anyone willing to identify the thief.   He also indicated that when he discovered who had stolen from him, he would stab and kill that person, and that he did not care about the consequences.

During the prison’s lunch period on December 21, the appellant called Baker over to him, and then hit him with his fists to knock him down.   During the attack, the victim continuously attempted to break free from Cox, and also denied stealing from him multiple times.   At a lull in the beating, the appellant said, “This ain’t good enough,” and stabbed Baker with an icepick-shaped shank [n.2] three times.   After the stabbing, Appellant walked away stating, “It ain’t over, I’ve got one more ․ to get.”   He then walked behind the prison pump house and hid the shiv in a pipe.   Cox proceeded from the pump house to his dorm, where he encountered Donny Cox (unrelated to the appellant).   There, Appellant questioned him about his stolen money and told him that if Cox had his money, he would kill him also.   Following this exchange, the appellant returned to his cell, where he next attacked his cellmate, Lawrence Wood, advising him that Wood was “lucky I put it up, or I’d get [you].”

While the appellant was returning to his cell, the stabbing victim fled the attack scene and ran to corrections officers in a nearby building.   The officers present at the time testified at trial that Baker had blood coming from his mouth, and that he was hysterically complaining that his lungs were filling with blood.   Baker also responded to the prison officials’ questions regarding who had attacked him by saying, “Big Al, Echo dorm, quad three.”   Although the corrections officers attempted to expedite emergency treatment of the victim by placing him on a stretcher and carrying him on foot to the prison medical center, Baker died before arriving at the hospital.

Doctor Janet Pillow testified that upon her autopsy of the victim, she found that the victim had been stabbed three times.   Two of the wounds inflicted were shallow punctures of the lower torso, but the fatal wound had entered the victim’s back and traveled through the chest cavity, between two ribs, and finally pierced the lungs and aorta.   She testified that a conscious person with this wound would suffer from “air hunger,” and would be aware of the “serious danger of dying.”   She described the wound as being approximately 17.5 centimeters deep, although only two millimeters wide.   Doctor Pillow verified that the shank found by the pump house was consistent with the victim’s injuries, despite the fact that the wound was deeper than the length of the weapon.   She attributed the discrepancy between the length of the weapon and the depth of the wound to the elasticity of human tissue.

The appellant also testified, contending that all of the previous witnesses were correct, except that they had not seen what truly happened when he, Baker, and Vincent Maynard, a third inmate, were close together.   According to Cox, it was he who had in fact dodged Baker and Maynard’s attempts to stab him, and it was Maynard who actually stabbed Baker in the back accidentally.   In Cox’s version of the events, he had only struck the victim because he was defending himself from both of the other attacking men.   Following the conclusion of the guilt phase testimony and argument, the jury deliberated, apparently rejected the view of the evidence offered by Cox, and found the appellant guilty of first-degree murder.

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/fl-supreme-court/1423634.html

Jeffrey Atwater Florida Death Row

jeffrey atwater

Jeffrey Atwater was sentenced to death by the State of Florida for the murder of Ken Smith. According to court documents Jeffrey Atwater would rob and murder Ken Smith inside of his residence. Jeffrey Atwater would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death

Florida Death Row Inmate List

Jeffrey Atwater 2021 Information

DC Number:120467
Name:ATWATER, JEFFREY
Race:WHITE
Sex:MALE
Birth Date:12/24/1963
Initial Receipt Date:07/10/1990
Current Facility:UNION C.I.
Current Custody:MAXIMUM
Current Release Date:DEATH SENTENCE

Jeffrey Atwater More News

On August 11, 1989, Atwater entered the John Knox Apartments in St. Petersburg, Florida, to see Ken Smith, the victim in this case.   Upon entering the apartment building, Atwater proceeded to Smith’s room where he remained for about twenty minutes.   After Atwater left, Smith’s body was discovered in the room.   Smith was dead and his money was missing.   Atwater told several people that he had killed Smith.   Atwater was arrested the same day for killing Smith.   At trial, he was convicted of first-degree murder and robbery.   The jury recommended death by a vote of eleven to one

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/fl-supreme-court/1495358.html

Louis Gaskin Florida Death Row

louis gaskin

Louis Gaskin was sentenced to death by the State of Florida for the murders of Robert and Georgette Sturmfels. According to court documents Louis Gaskin would fatally shoot Robert and Georgette Sturmfels during a robbery at their residence. Louis Gaskin would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death

Florida Death Row Inmate List

Louis Gaskin 2021 Information

DC Number:751166
Name:GASKIN, LOUIS B
Race:BLACK
Sex:MALE
Birth Date:03/11/1967
Initial Receipt Date:07/19/1990
Current Facility:UNION C.I.
Current Custody:MAXIMUM
Current Release Date:DEATH SENTENCE

Louis Gaskin More News

A husband and wife were assassinated inside their Palm Coast home the night of Dec. 20, 1989.

It wasn’t the first murder the gunman, Louis Gaskin, committed and it wouldn’t be his last attempt. He fired at another couple inside their home later that night in the same neighborhood, critically injuring one of them.

It’s been surmised by law enforcement that Gaskin would have continued to indulge his homicidal tendencies had he not made one costly mistake. He passed off the items he had stolen from inside the slain couple’s home as Christmas presents.

Six months later, the 22-year-old Gaskin was sentenced to the electric chair for the double murder. Twenty-nine years later, he still sits on death row.

Gaskin told a psychologist before his trial that he was fully aware of what he was doing when he dressed up as a ninja and murdered Robert and Georgette Sturmfels.

“The guilt was always there,” Gaskin told him. “The devil had more of a hold than God did. I knew that I was wrong. I wasn’t insane.”

Robert and Georgette Sturmfels, 56 and 55 years old, were part-time residents of Palm Coast. Three years earlier, the New Jersey couple bought a house at 10 Ripley Place and spent their winters there. Today, Palm Coast is filled with single-family homes, but in 1989, Palm Coast was still 10 years away from becoming a city and the community was still comprised mostly of wide-open spaces. Sturmfels’ house sat alone on a cul-de-sac and was surrounded by woods.

Gaskin, who lived in neighboring Bunnell, decided on a whim to dress like a ninja and go on the prowl looking for victims.

He came upon the Sturmfels house and noticed the couple sitting in their family room. Gaskin circled around five times before convincing himself to go through with it. He found a spot where he could get a clean shot and remain hidden.

The first shot struck Robert Strumfels in the chest. He stood up from his chair and clutched his chest. That startled his wife. Seconds later, Gaskin fired at Georgette Strumfels, striking her. He entered the house and shot both of them at point-blank range. He chased Georgette Sturmfels down the hall.

Flagler County Sheriff’s Sr. Cmdr. Mark Carman was a major crimes detective at the time of the shooting. He was one of four investigators who worked the case. He recalled Gaskin describing the sounds Sturmfels made after he shot her. Gaskin said it reminded him of when a hog gets killed.

“He called it the death gurgle,” Carman said.

Before he left, Gaskin took a clock, a pair of lamps and a videocassette recorder from the house. He loaded them in his car and left.

He couldn’t find his way back onto Royal Palms Parkway and wound up on another dead-end street. He saw a light come on inside a house on Ricker Place. He decided in that moment to take out two more people.

He didn’t have a clear shot this time, so he tried to lure the people outside. He cut the outside telephone cord and threw logs and rocks onto the roof.

Joe and Nadeen Rector heard the racket and got spooked. One of them picked up a phone and tried to call police, but the line was dead. They walked into the master bedroom to try another phone and that’s when Gaskin opened fire on them. The bullet missed Rector, but struck her husband in the torso. He stumbled outside and yelled into the darkness before his wife led him to the car.

They pulled out of the driveway and headed for the nearest hospital. As they pulled out, Gaskin fired five .22-caliber rounds at them, striking the body of the car. None of those bullets struck the Rectors. Doctors saved Joe Rector’s life, but it was a close call. The couple had even said their goodbyes to each other during the ride to the hospital.

Deputies showed up en masse to the Rector home the morning of Dec. 21, 1989. They collected casings, footprints and tire tracks. The gunman had also entered the home, so forensic specialists searched for fingerprints.

By early afternoon, the Sheriff’s Office got a call from a U.S. Postal Service employee. A mail carrier saw two bodies lying inside a home less than a mile south of Rector. Detectives were astonished to find a crime scene even worse than the one they had been working all morning.

“That’s the first capital murder case I ever worked on,” Carman said. Flagler was not a place rife with gun violence, especially in 1989.

The first break in the case came when a confidential informant for the Bunnell Police Department came forward with some information. The police referred him to the Sheriff’s Office. The deputy who interviewed the informant was then-Sgt. Warnell Williams.

The informant told Williams he was in possession of the rifle used in the shootings. He also said his sister, who was dating Gaskin, had some possessions that may have been stolen from the house where the Sturmfels were killed.

“He had saved some of that stuff to give to (his girlfriend) for Christmas,” Williams said.

Gaskin told the informant that he had “jacked” the gifts and had left the victims “stiff,” according to the Sheriff’s Office.

Carman and another detective arrested Gaskin the morning of Dec. 29, 1989, outside his friend’s home on Hyman Circle. He was brought in for questioning.

He promised to tell detectives everything as long as he was allowed to smoke.

Carman drove from the jail to a nearby convenience store to get Gaskin’s a pack of Black & Mild cigars.

“I sat there and watched him smoke while he told his story,” Carman said. “To this day, I can’t stand the smell of Black & Mild cigars.”

Gaskin, as promised, confessed to everything. In addition to his rampage the night of Dec. 20, 1989, he confessed to killing a co-worker in 1986. He also confessed to shooting and injuring a woman outside a Daytona Beach bank in the summer of 1989. The woman was a retail manager and was making a late-night drop.

In June 1990, Gaskin was convicted of all his charges, including multiple counts of first-degree and attempted first-degree murder.

Gaskin was a brash young man when he killed the Sturmfels. Nowadays he’s a haggard 51-year-old with glasses and a salt-and-pepper beard. For nearly three decades, he has spent 23 hours per day in solitary confinement.

https://www.news-journalonline.com/news/20190130/ninja-killer-of-flagler-county-arrested-29-years-ago-remains-on-death-row

William Deparvine Florida Death Row

William Deparvine

William Deparvine was sentenced to death by the State of Florida for a robbery and double murder. According to court documents William Deparvine approached the couple: Richard Van Dusen and Karla Van Dusen, about purchasing a vintage pickup truck. When he arrived William Deparvine would drive with the couple to a remote location and would fatally shoot both before stealing the truck. William Deparvine would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death

Florida Death Row Inmate List

William Deparvine 2021 Information

DC Number:256512
Name:DEPARVINE, WILLIAM J
Race:WHITE
Sex:MALE
Birth Date:04/21/1952
Initial Receipt Date:09/13/1990
Current Facility:UNION C.I.
Current Custody:MAXIMUM
Current Release Date:PENDING

William Deparvine More News

A Florida death row inmate is suing to get a vintage Chevy pickup owned by the couple he is convicted of killing.

William Deparvine was sentenced to death in 2006 for killing Richard and Karla Van Dusen.

His lawsuit over their car has now dragged on for two years, the St. Petersburg Times reported.

The dispute is over a red 1971 Chevrolet Cheyenne truck Van Dusen bought and refurbished in the late 1990s after he divorced.

He went to weekend car shows with it and won trophies.

After he remarried, however, he decided to sell the truck, and Deparvine responded to a classified ad he took out.

On Nov. 26, 2003, the day after Deparvine met with Van Dusen, 58, and his wife, 49, their bodies were found in a dirt driveway in northwest Hillsborough County.

Both had been shot in the head.

Authorities said Deparvine planned to rob and kill the couple but wanted to make it look like he bought the truck and someone else shot them.

He typed up a bill of sale indicating the truck had been sold for $6,500 and signed Richard Van Dusen’s name.

At trial, Deparvine, 57, claimed he was innocent, but jurors found him guilty and sentenced him to death.

From his cell, he has claimed the bill of sale proves he owns the truck, and he has filed pages of handwritten court pleadings in his case.

“I will have to give him credit,” said Robert Vessel, an attorney for Richard Van Dusen’s daughter.

“He’s one of the best jailhouse lawyers I’ve seen.”

It may not be enough to get the truck back. Van Dusen’s daughter said her cousin helped her sell it soon after Deparvine’s conviction.

She was too scared to sell the truck on her own because of what happened to her father

https://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/trending/sfl-mtblog-2009-06-death_row_inmate_sues_for_truc-story.html

Mark Geralds Florida Death Row

mark geralds

Mark Geralds was sentenced to death by the State of Florida for the robbery and murder of Tressa Pettibone. According to court documents Mark Geralds would murder Tressa Pettibone during a robbery at her residence. Mark Geralds would be arrested, convicted and sentenced to death

Florida Death Row Inmate List

Mark Geralds 2021 Information

DC Number:729185
Name:GERALDS, MARK
Race:WHITE
Sex:MALE
Birth Date:03/29/1967
Initial Receipt Date:09/14/1990
Current Facility:UNION C.I.
Current Custody:MAXIMUM
Current Release Date:DEATH SENTENCE

Mark Geralds More News

A death row inmate convicted of murdering a Panama City woman 20 years ago will stay in prison after the Florida Supreme Court ruled against him Thursday.

In a 61-page ruling, the court affirmed a Circuit Court ruling that denied a motion by Mark Geralds to vacate his conviction and death sentence and release him from prison.

Geralds was convicted in 1990 of entering the home of 33-year-old Tressa Pettibone, beating her unconscious, binding her hands and stabbing her three times in the throat. A jury recommended the death penalty.

In 1992, the Supreme Court upheld the conviction but ordered a new sentencing hearing. A new jury unanimously recommended the death penalty in 1993. Court records noted Geralds’ high IQ of 121 and his “superior ability to think in the abstract” were inconsistent with the notion that Geralds acted out of sudden rage.

The Supreme Court in 1996 unanimously denied Geralds’ request for a new hearing and affirmed the death sentence against him.

Geralds had been a carpenter and had worked on a remodeling job at the Pettibone home. He saw Tressa Pettibone at a mall with her two children a week before the murder. He found out Kevin Pettibone, Tressa’s husband, was out of town for several weeks, and he asked her children what time they left for and returned from school each day.

“Geralds carefully planned this crime,” the Supreme Court noted in 1992.

Geralds was 22 years old when Pettibone was killed. He is now 43. Calls to Geralds’ defense attorney were not returned.

According to Roger Maas with the Capital Collateral Regional Counsels, an office that monitors death penalty cases in the state, there are roughly 10 death sentences handed down each year statewide.

Capital cases automatically appeal to the Florida Supreme Court, but such cases are so complex that the court can only rule on two or three a year. Those two or three death penalty appeals take up about 50 percent of the Florida Supreme Court’s time, Maas said.

O.H. Eaton, an 18th Circuit Court Judge and the longtime head of faculty at the Florida College for Advanced Judicial Studies, teaches a course on how to handle capital cases at the State’s Judicial College and the National Judicial College in Reno, Nev. The course is mandatory for any judge who might deal with death penalty cases.

Eaton said Geralds’ appeal just passed the fifth step in what is typically a nine-step process. The next step would be an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, which is likely to be denied until the federal appeals process, which can take as long as federal judges deem necessary, has been exhausted and the case is fully developed.

“At any step in this process the case can get kicked back one or more steps,” Eaton said.

Since 1979, when the death penalty was reinstated in Florida, the average length of time a prisoner spends on death row is just under 13 years, according to the Department of Corrections. Before 1997, when the appeals system was reorganized, it often took as long as 20 years to execute a convict, Maas said.

There are currently about 50 death row inmates who’ve exhausted their appeals and are only waiting for a death warrant from the governor, Maas said. There were 391 death row inmates in Florida as of Sept. 17.

The prisoner most recently executed in Florida was Martin Grossman, who had been on death row more than 24 years before he was put to death Feb. 16.